CAFC

13-1250

Virtual Solutions v. Microsoft

General

Filed03/14/13

Appeal FromS.D. New York

Originating Case1:12-cv-01118

Decision11/08/13

Appeal OutcomeAppellee

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Timothy B. Dyk	500+	67%	46%
Haldane R. Mayer	200+	63%	40%
Raymond T. Chen	2	100%	0%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Virtual Solutions LLC NPE	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Simon Law Firm	L1 D
Anthony G. Simon	L2 E
Benjamin R. Askew	-- -- --
Michael P. Kella	-- -- --
Stephanie H. To	-- -- --
Innovalaw	-- -- --
Timothy E. Grochocinski	L4 A

No Attorneys

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Microsoft Corp	L5 B

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Fish & Richardson	L5 E
Lauren A. Degnan	L2 C
Ruffin B. Cordell	L2 D
Cherylyn E. Mizzo	-- -- --
Leah A. Edelman	-- -- --
Robert Courtney	-- -- --
Microsoft Corp	-- -- --
Stacy Quan	-- -- --

No Attorneys