CAFC
16-2457
Smartflash LLC v. Apple Inc
General
Filed08/10/16
Appeal FromPTAB
Originating CaseCBM2015-00016
Decision04/11/18
Appeal OutcomeAppellee
PACER16-2457
Judges
Judge | Cases | PO Affirm Rate | Ch Affirm Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alan D. Lourie | 900+ | 75% | 32% |
| Timothy B. Dyk | 1000+ | 75% | 44% |
| Richard G. Taranto | 500+ | 69% | 22% |
Appellant
Attorney
Name | Ratings |
|---|---|
L3 E | |
L4 E | |
-- -- -- | |
L1 D | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- |
No Attorneys
Appellee
Party
Name | Ratings |
|---|---|
L5 A | |
L5 A | |
L4 B | |
L4 B | |
United States Patent Trademark Office | -- -- -- |
No Parties
Attorney
Name | Ratings |
|---|---|
L5 C | |
L5 A | |
-- -- -- | |
L5 D | |
L4 C | |
L3 D | |
-- -- -- | |
L4 C | |
L5 E | |
L1 B | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
L3 B | |
L3 E | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- | |
L3 C | |
L4 B | |
-- -- -- | |
L2 C | |
-- -- -- |
No Attorneys