CAFC

20-1701

Iron Oak Technologies LLC v. Microsoft Corp

General

Filed04/14/20

Appeal FromPTAB

Originating CaseIPR2018-01552

Decision05/24/21

Appeal OutcomeAppellee

Judges

Judge	Cases	PO Affirm Rate	Ch Affirm Rate
Alan D. Lourie	1000+	79%	33%
Haldane R. Mayer	500+	73%	36%
Kathleen M. O'Malley	1000+	75%	28%

Appellant

Party

Name	Ratings
Iron Oak Technologies LLC NPE	L2 D

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
McAughan Deaver PLLC	L4 B
Albert B. Deaver, Jr.	L1 C
Robert J. McAughan, Jr.	L1 D

No Attorneys

Appellee

Party

Name	Ratings
Microsoft Corp	L5 A
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5 A
Google LLC	L5 A

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Smith Baluch LLP	L5 A
Andrew Baluch	-- -- --
Matthew A. Smith	-- -- --
Sidley Austin LLP	L5 B
Joseph A. Micallef	L2 B
Richard A. Cederoth	L1 C
Scott M. Border	-- -- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L5 B
Naveen Modi	L3 A
Stephen B. Kinnaird	L3 B
Joseph E. Palys	L1 C
Phillip Citroen	-- -- --
Anderson To	-- -- --

No Attorneys