DCT

8:12-cv-01659

Lochner Tech LLC v. Apple Inc

General

Filed

10/01/12

Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (09/13/13)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER

8:12-cv-01659

Appeals

13-1551

CourtC.D. California

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Mariana R. Pfaelzer	10/16/12 - 09/04/14	20%
James R. Gilstrap	12/20/11 - 10/16/12	36%
David Folsom	10/05/11 - 09/18/12	41%
Leonard E. Davis	01/04/12 - 01/06/12	35%
T. John Ward	09/12/11 - 10/05/11	53%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Lochner Technologies LLC NPE	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Davis FirmLocal	L2 D
William E. Davis, III	L4 E
Russ August & Kabat	L2 E
Marc A. Fenster	L5 E
Stanley H. Thompson, Jr.	L4 E
Bruce D. Kuyper	L3 D
Fredricka Ung	L3 E
Brian D. Ledahl	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5 A
Sony-Ericsson Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5 A
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5 A
Sony Electronics Inc	L5 A
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5 A
Google LLC	L5 A
Google Inc	L5 A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5 C
Toshiba America Information Systems Inc	L4 A
toshiba America Inc	L4 A
Panasonic Corp	L4 A
Nokia USA Inc	L4 A
Nokia Inc	L4 A
Motorola Mobility LLC	L4 A
Motorola Mobility Inc	L4 A
Amazon.com Inc	L4 A
Cisco Systems Inc	L4 A
Acer America Inc	L4 E
Acer America Corp	L4 E
Research in Motion Ltd	L3 A
Research In Motion Corp	L3 A
ASUS Computer Intl Inc	L3 B
Roku Inc	L3 B
NEC Corp	L2 B
Viewsonic Corp	L2 C
Vizio Inc	L2 E
Casio America Inc	L1 C
Samsung Electrionics America Inc	-- -- --
Unisys Corp	-- -- --
HTC America Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP	L5 A
David J. Levy	L3 A
Jerry R. Selinger	L3 E
Robert W. Busby, Jr.	L2 A
Perkins Coie LLP	L5 A
Ryan J. McBrayer	L3 E
Kirkland & Ellis LLP	L5 A
Kristina Hendricks	-- -- --
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5 A
Steven J. Moore	L5 A
Russell A. Korn	L3 A
E. Danielle Thompson Williams	L3 A
Jessica Lea Hannah	L2 A
Andrews Kurth Kenyon LLP	L5 A
John H. McDowell, Jr.	L3 A
Benjamin J. Setnick	L2 B
Blank Rome LLP	L5 A
Keith A. Rutherford	L4 C
Louis Brucculeri	L3 B
Susan K. Knoll	L2 E
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Allen F. Gardner	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L5 A
Michael C. Smith	L5 A
Alston & Bird LLP	L5 A
Rachel M. Capoccia	L3 A
Louis A. Karasik	L2 B
Mitra M. Eskandari-Azari	-- -- --
Mitra E. Azari	-- -- --
Jones Day	L5 A
Kenneth R. Adamo	L5 E
Ya-Chiao Chang	L2 C
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5 B
Melissa R. Smith	L5 A
McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP	L5 B
Renzo N. Rocchegiani	L2 C
R. Tyler Goodwyn, IV	L2 D
Song K. Jung	L1 C
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5 B
Doris J. Hines	L2 B
Jason Stach	-- -- --
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5 E
Charles Ainsworth	L5 E
Covington & Burling LLP	L4 A
Robert T. Haslam	L5 A
Christine S. Haskett	L2 B
Michael K. Plimack	L2 E
Kirran Bari	-- -- --
Findlay CraftLocal	L4 B
Eric H. Findlay	L5 A
Roger B. Craft	L5 E
Duane Morris LLP	L4 D
Wesley W. Yuan	L2 A
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L5 E
Haltom & DoanLocal	L3 A
Jennifer H. Doan	L5 A
Shawn A. Latchford	-- -- --
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L3 A
Michael E. Richardson	L5 A
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	L4 A
Robert D. Daniel	L3 B
Young Pickett & LeeLocal	L3 B
John M. Pickett	L5 B
Haynes & Boone LLP	L3 B
Phillip B. Philbin	L5 A
John R. Emerson	L4 A
Donald E. Tiller	L3 E
Ramey & FlockLocal	L3 B
Deron R. Dacus	L5 A
King & Spalding LLP	L3 E
Robert F. Perry	L5 A
Allison H. Altersohn	L4 C
Steven T. Snyder	L3 D
Lerner David Littenberg Krumholz & Mentlik LLP	L3 E
Gregory S. Gewirtz	L4 B
Robert B. Hander	L2 E
Orville R. Cockings	-- -- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L3 E
Allan M. Soobert	L3 D
Steven Lee Park	-- -- --
Tumer Boyd LLP	L2 C
Joshua M. Masur	L4 A
Karen I. Boyd	L4 C
Steven W. Flanders	L3 D
Blakely Sokoloff Taylor Zafman	L1 B
Willmore F. Holbrow, III	L4 A
Dennis G. Martin	L3 A
Glaser Weil Fink Howard Avchen & Shapiro LLP	L1 C
Adrian M. Pruetz	L4 D
Avraham Schwartz	-- -- --
Charles C. Koole	-- -- --
Techknowledge Law Group LLP	L1 C
Kaiwen Tseng	L4 D
Lee Tran & Liang LLP	L1 D
Enoch H. Liang	L3 B
Steven R. Hansen	L2 B
Sills Cummis Epstein & Gross	L1 E
Scott D. Stimpson	L1 E
David C. Lee	-- -- --
Katherine M. Lieb	-- -- --
Hardy & AthertonLocal	-- -- --
John M. Hardy	-- -- --
Lee Jorgensen Pyle &Kewalarmani	-- -- --
Hemant H. Kewalramani	-- -- --

No Attorneys