Melissa R. Smith

Alan E. Littmann

Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.

Michael T. Pieja

Doug Winnard

Andrew J. Rima

Kenneth F. Baum

Jennifer Greenblatt

Lauren Abendshien

Emma Ross

Shu Zhang

Robert R. Gilman

Edward R. Nelson, III

Brian A. Tollefson

Paul J. Hayes

Anthony M. Vecchione

Dean G. Bostock

James J. Foster

Kevin Gannon

Aaron S. Jacobs

Michael J. Ercolini

Matthew D. Vella

Tyrus S. Cartwright

IPR narrows suit vs. Apple over the TV Remote app. A lone surviving claim targets tech for controlling a remote application that `cannot be executed` on an iPhone.

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
William H. Alsup	03/01/18 - 05/12/22	29%
Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr.	01/26/18 - 03/01/18	24%
James R. Gilstrap	08/03/17 - 01/26/18	36%

Name	Ratings
Uniloc USA Inc NPE	L5 E
Uniloc 2017 LLC NPE	L5 E

Name	Ratings
Nelson Bumgardner AlbrittonLocal	L4 D
Edward R. Nelson, III	L5 E
Nelson Bumgardner ConroyLocal	L4 D
Anthony M. Vecchione	L5 E
Prince Lobel Tye LLP	L3 E
Robert R. Gilman	L5 E
Paul J. Hayes	L5 E
Dean G. Bostock	L5 E
James J. Foster	L5 E
Michael J. Ercolini	L5 E
Kevin Gannon	L5 E
Aaron S. Jacobs	L5 E
Brian A. Tollefson	L3 D
Matthew D. Vella	L1 B
Tyrus S. Cartwright	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5 A
Melissa R. Smith	L5 A
Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.	L5 A
Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan Baum LLP	L2 C
Alan E. Littmann	L4 A
Michael T. Pieja	L4 B
Doug Winnard	L4 D
Jennifer Greenblatt	L2 A
Emma Ross	L2 A
Lauren Abendshien	L2 D
Andrew J. Rima	-- -- --
Kenneth F. Baum	-- -- --
Shu Zhang	-- -- --

3:18-cv-00365

Uniloc USA Inc v. Apple Inc