Darin W. Snyder

Luann L. Simmons

Robert L. Maier

David S. Almeling

Neil P. Sirota

Kevin M. Sadler

Melissa R. Smith

Bill Trac

Mark Liang

Gregory B. Thompson

J. Mark Mann

Amy K. Liang

Sorin G. Zaharia

Margaret Welsh

Andrew Bledsoe

Stacy Yae

Alfred R. Fabricant

Samuel F. Baxter

Benjamin T. Wang

Peter Lambrianakos

Jennifer L. Truelove

Vincent J. Rubino, III

Minna Chan

Enrique Iturralde

Sarah G. Hartman

First responder patents target Samsung's 'Find My Device' feature, accusing phones over `remotely controlling` a device after joining an ad hoc `group`.

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Beth L. Freeman	08/31/22 - 02/20/24	5%
James R. Gilstrap	11/05/19 - 08/31/22	35%

Name	Ratings
McKool Smith	L5 E
Samuel F. Baxter	L5 A
Jennifer L. Truelove	L5 E
Russ August & Kabat	L4 E
Benjamin T. Wang	L5 E
Minna Chan	L3 C
Brown Rudnick LLP	L2 B
Peter Lambrianakos	L4 A
Alfred R. Fabricant	L4 D
Vincent J. Rubino, III	L3 D
Sarah G. Hartman	L2 B
Fabricant LLPLocal	L2 D
Enrique Iturralde	L2 D

Name	Ratings
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5 A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5 A

Name	Ratings
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5 A
Melissa R. Smith	L5 A
Baker Botts LLP	L5 B
Robert L. Maier	L4 A
Neil P. Sirota	L4 A
Kevin M. Sadler	L1 E
Margaret Welsh	-- -- --
O Melveny & Myers	L4 B
Luann L. Simmons	L5 A
Darin W. Snyder	L5 E
David S. Almeling	L4 D
Mark Liang	L3 A
Bill Trac	L2 C
Stacy Yae	L1 C
Andrew Bledsoe	L1 D
O'Melveny & Myers LLP	L4 B
Amy K. Liang	L3 C
Sorin G. Zaharia	L2 A
Mann Tindel & ThompsonLocal	L3 B
J. Mark Mann	L5 A
Gregory B. Thompson	L5 B

5:22-cv-04825

AGIS Software Development LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co Ltd