DCT

1:06-cv-00404

St Clair IP Consultants Inc v. LG Electronics Inc

General

Filed

06/26/06

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (09/04/12)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Joseph J. Farnan, Jr.	07/05/06 - 09/18/13	64%

Magistrate

Leonard P. Stark

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
St Clair Intellectual Property Consultants Inc NPE	L1 C

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Richards Layton & Finger PALocal	L5 A
Frederick L. Cottrell, III	L5 A
Laura D. Hatcher	L2 C
Chad M. Shandler	L2 D
Elizabeth Rui He	L1 B
Gregory E. Stuhlman	L1 B
Michelle E. Whalen	-- -- --
Robins Kaplan LLP	L4 E
Ronald J. Schutz	L5 E
Annie Huang	L2 B
Becky R. Thorson	L2 C
Busola A. Akinwale	L2 D
Brock J. Specht	L2 D
Mathew J. Yang	L2 D
Trevor J. Foster	L2 E
Seth A. Northrop	L1 C
David B. Zucco	-- -- --
William J. Rocha	-- -- --
Tara D. Falsani	-- -- --
Shira T. Shapiro	-- -- --
Melissa A. Goodman	-- -- --
Carrie M. Lambert	-- -- --
Lauren J. Galgano	-- -- --
Andrea L. Gothing	-- -- --
Lars P. Taavola	-- -- --
Rader Fishman	L2 D
R. Terrance Rader	L5 D
Glenn E. Forbis	L4 E
Charles W. Bradley	L2 E
Seitz van Ogtrop & Green PALocal	-- -- --
Patricia P. McGonigle	-- -- --
Jared T. Green	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5 E
LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA Inc	L5 E
LG Electronics Inc	-- -- --
Motorola Wuhan Mobility Technologies Communication Co Ltd	L4 A
T-Mobile USA Inc	L4 A
T-Mobile Intl Ag	L4 A
Deutsche Telekom AG	L4 A
Sanyo North America Corp	L4 A
Sanyo Electric Co Ltd	L4 A
Palm Inc	L2 A
HTC Corp	L2 A
HTC BVI Corp	L2 A
HTC America Inc	L2 A
Kyocera Wireless Corp	L2 B
Kyocera Communications Inc	L2 B
High Tech Computer Corp	L1 B
Polaroid Holding Co	L1 C
Polaroid Corp	L1 C
Polaroid Consumer Electronics LLC	L1 C
Petters Group Worldwide LLC	L1 C
Concord Camera Corp	-- -- --
Aiptek Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Kirkland & Ellis LLP	L5 A
Russell E. Levine	L4 D
Melody D. Hansen	-- -- --
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLPLocal	L5 A
Jack B. Blumenfeld	L5 A
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
David C. Doyle	L5 A
Brian M. Kramer	L4 E
Mark A. Woodmansee	L3 A
Gregory W. Reilly	L2 B
Christian G. Andreu-Von Euw	-- -- --
Edwin D. Buxton	-- -- --
Philip A. Morin	-- -- --
Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor LLPLocal	L5 A
Karen E. Keller	L4 E
Megan C. Haney	L2 B
Melanie K. Sharp	L2 E
James L. Higgins	L1 C
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP	L5 A
Christopher P. Broderick	L3 B
Robert J. Benson	L2 C
Bingham McCutchen LLP	L5 A
Richard De Bodo	L5 B
Alston & Bird LLP	L5 B
Rachel M. Capoccia	L2 A
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4 E
John G. Day	L4 E
Lauren E. Maguire	L3 E
Ratner Prestia	L3 B
Gerard M. O'Rourke	L2 B
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3 B
David H. Ben-Meir	L3 A
Raymond A. Kurz	L2 E
Andrew V. Devkar	-- -- --
Proskauer Rose LLP	L3 C
Steven M. Bauer	L5 D
Kimberly A. Mottley	L4 D
Bayard PALocal	L3 E
Richard D. Kirk	L3 C
Invista Sarl	-- -- --
Stephen J. MacKenzie	-- -- --

No Attorneys