DCT

1:12-cv-01533

Pragmatus Telecom LLC v. Newegg Inc

General

Filed

11/21/12

Cause of ActionInfringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (02/18/16)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER

1:12-cv-01533

Appeals

14-1777

CourtD. Delaware

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Richard G. Andrews	12/13/12 - 03/01/16	27%

Magistrate

Mary Pat Thynge

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Pragmatus Telecom LLC NPE	L2 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Farnan LLPLocal	L4 E
Brian E. Farnan	L4 E
Sal Lim	-- -- --
David Alberti	-- -- --
Feinberg Day Alberti & Thompson LLP	L2 C
Margaret E. Day	L5 A
Marc Belloli	L5 A
Ian N. Feinberg	L4 A
Clayton Thompson	L3 A
Yakov Zolotorev	L3 B
Vinay K. Malik	L1 C

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Newegg Inc	L3 A
Lenovo United States Inc	L5 A
EMC Corp	L5 A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L5 A
AT&T Inc	L5 A
Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc	L5 A
3M Innovative Properties Co	L5 A
3M Co Inc	L5 A
PerkinElmer Inc	L4 A
Sprint Spectrum LP	L4 A
Oriental Trading Co Inc	L4 B
Staples Inc	L3 A
Office Depot LLC	L3 A
Office Depot Inc	L3 A
Neweggcom Inc	L3 A
HSN LP	L3 A
HSN Inc	L3 A
General Motors LLC	L3 A
Volkswagen Group of America Inc	L3 B
Rite-Aid Corp	L3 B
Bosch Security Systems LLC	L3 B
CDW LLC	L2 A
First Data Corp	L2 A
Frontier Communications Corp NPE	L2 B
Thomson Reuters Corp	L2 B
Elavon Inc	L2 B
Goemerchant LLC	L2 B
Starwood Hotels Resorts Worldwide Inc	L2 D
Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide Inc	L2 D
Seagate Technology US Holdings Inc	L2 E
Seagate Technology LLC	L2 E
Seagate Technology Holdings Inc	L2 E
Crocs Inc	L1 B
Brother Intl Corp	L1 B
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories Inc	L1 B
Reed Elsevier US Holdings Inc	L1 C
Sakscom LLC	L1 C
Syntellect Inc	L1 D
Enghouse Interactive Inc	L1 D
Apropos Technology Inc	L1 D
U-Haul Intl Inc	L1 D
U Haul Intl Inc	L1 D
eGain Corp	-- -- --
Aramark Corp	-- -- --
Aramark	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnell LLPLocal	L5 A
Jack B. Blumenfeld	L5 A
Rodger D. Smith, II	L4 A
Karen Jacobs	L4 B
Michael J. Flynn	L3 A
Mary B. Graham	L3 A
Paul Saindon	L2 A
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5 A
Steven J. Moore	L5 A
William H. Boice	L5 A
Michael Morlock	L2 B
John C. Alemanni	L2 B
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
Karen L. Hagberg	L3 B
Craig B. Whitney	-- -- --
Potter Anderson & Corroon LLPLocal	L5 A
Richard L. Horwitz	L5 A
David E. Moore	L5 A
Philip A. Rovner	L3 C
Bindu Ann George Palapura	L3 C
Fish & Richardson	L5 B
Neil J. McNabnay	L5 A
Susan Morrison	L4 C
William C. Shear	L4 C
P. Weston Musselman, Jr.	L3 B
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati	L5 B
Vera M. Elson	L4 B
Larry L. Shatzer	-- -- --
Kate P. Mahaffy	-- -- --
Paul M. McAdams	-- -- --
Anthony J. Weibell	-- -- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 B
John M. Guaragna	L5 D
Denise S. Kraft	L5 D
Brian A. Biggs	L4 B
Aleine M. Porterfield	L2 B
James M. Heintz	L2 B
Courtney Stewart	-- -- --
McDermott Will & Emery LLP	L5 B
Hasan M. Rashid	L2 C
Alston & Bird LLP	L4 A
Jason W. Cook	-- -- --
Shaun W. Hassett	-- -- --
Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP	L4 A
Patrick J. Kelleher	L3 D
Carrie A. Beyer	L2 E
Todd C. Schiltz	-- -- --
Faegre Baker Daniels LLP	L4 A
Natalie Hanlon-Leh	L3 A
Jared B. Briant	L2 B
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4 B
Steven J. Balick	L5 D
Andrew C. Mayo	L4 A
John G. Day	L4 B
Lauren E. Maguire	L4 C
Locke Lord LLP	L4 B
John F. Sweeney	L4 C
Steven F. Meyer	L2 B
Joseph A. Farco	L2 C
Sergey Kolmykov	L1 C
Duane Morris LLP	L4 D
L. Norwood Jameson	L4 C
Gary W. Lipkin	L3 D
John R. Gibson	L2 A
Benjamin A. Smyth	-- -- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L4 E
Elizabeth L. Brann	-- -- --
Thomas A. Counts	-- -- --
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3 A
Eric J. Klein	L4 A
Fred I. Williams	L4 A
John Wittenzellner	L1 B
Marshall Gerstein & Borun LLP	L3 A
Tron Y. Fu	L1 C
GibbonsLocal	L3 B
David E. De Lorenzi	L3 A
Christopher H. Strate	-- -- --
Christopher Viceconte	-- -- --
Proskauer Rose LLP	L3 B
Steven M. Bauer	L5 A
Kimberly A. Mottley	L4 B
Joel Cavanaugh	L1 C
Wiley Rein LLP	L3 C
Anthony H. Son	-- -- --
Ryan M. Corbett	-- -- --
Polsinelli	L3 E
Russell S. Jones, Jr.	L3 A
Shanti M. Katona	L2 D
Richard P. Stitt	L1 B
Joshua McCaig	L1 B
Christopher M. Coggins	-- -- --
Seyfarth Shaw LLP	L2 C
Joseph R. Lanser	L2 A
Vamsi Kakarla	-- -- --
Webb Law Firm	L2 C
Kent E. Baldauf, Jr.	L4 B
Daniel H. Brean	L2 B
Ross Aronstam & Moritz LLPLocal	L2 C
Benjamin J. Schladweiler	L2 C
Seitz Ross Aronstam & Moritz LLPLocal	L2 C
Collins J. Seitz, Jr.	L2 C
Desmarais LLP	L2 D
Jon T. Hohenthaner	L4 B
Lowe Graham Jones PLLC	L2 D
Lawrence D. Graham	L5 B
Proctor Heyman LLPLocal	L2 E
Dominick T. Gattuso	L2 E
Choate Hall & Stewart LLP	L1 C
Carlos Perez-Albuerne	L2 B
G. Mark Edgarton	L1 D
Carlos Perez	-- -- --
Anita Spieth	-- -- --
Ward Zinna	L1 D
Michael J. Zinna	L4 A
Patrick R. Colsher	L2 C
Abrams & Bayliss LLPLocal	L1 D
John M. Seaman	L2 C

No Attorneys