DCT

1:14-cv-01270

F'real Foods LLC v. Hamilton Beach Brands Inc

Log In

I. Executive Summary and Procedural Information

  • Parties & Counsel:
  • Case Identification: 1:14-cv-01270, D. Del., 10/03/2014
  • Venue Allegations: Venue is alleged to be proper as each defendant has conducted acts of infringement, does business, and/or resides in the District of Delaware.
  • Core Dispute: Plaintiff alleges that Defendant’s self-serve frozen drink kiosks and blenders infringe four patents related to the methods and apparatus for making and aerating frozen drinks and for automatically sanitizing the blender components.
  • Technical Context: The technology concerns automated, self-service machines for preparing milkshakes and other frozen beverages, a segment that aims to bring high-quality, blended drinks to high-traffic retail environments like convenience stores.
  • Key Procedural History: The complaint alleges that Defendant Hamilton Beach previously entered into a license agreement for three of the four patents-in-suit (’150, ’658, and ’662 patents), which it later terminated. This prior relationship is the foundation for the allegations of willful infringement.

Case Timeline

Date Event
1996-05-17 Earliest Priority Date for '377 Patent
1998-09-08 '377 Patent Issued
2002-11-15 Earliest Priority Date for '150, '658, and '662 Patents
2006-12-05 '150 Patent Issued
2009-04-21 '658 Patent Issued
2009-04-21 '662 Patent Issued
2011-08-02 Hamilton Beach terminates license agreement for '150, '658, '662 patents
~2013 Hamilton Beach and Hershey Creamery launch accused products
2014-10-03 Complaint Filed

II. Technology and Patent(s)-in-Suit Analysis

U.S. Patent No. 5,803,377 - Apparatus And Method For Making Frozen Drinks (Issued Sep. 8, 1998)

The Invention Explained

  • Problem Addressed: The patent identifies the challenge of producing high-quality, "old fashioned" style milkshakes in high-volume, fast-food environments, where traditional blending methods are too slow and labor-intensive, and dispensing freezers produce a product with an undesirable, homogeneous texture ('377 Patent, col. 1:12-40). A further challenge is ensuring the equipment can be cleaned easily to avoid bacterial growth ('377 Patent, col. 1:56-65).
  • The Patented Solution: The invention is an automated machine that takes a serving cup pre-filled with a frozen, non-aerated substance. A rotating blade assembly is lowered into the cup to grind the frozen block while liquid (e.g., milk) is simultaneously added. The blade is specially designed not only to grind the substance but also to whip or aerate the mixture, creating the desired texture and volume ('377 Patent, Abstract; col. 3:12-30). A spring-loaded mechanism allows the blade to descend at a rate dictated by the hardness of the frozen substance, rather than at a fixed mechanical speed ('377 Patent, col. 8:31-47).
  • Technical Importance: This approach enabled the placement of self-serve, high-quality milkshake machines in new commercial venues by automating a complex process and reducing preparation time to under 30 seconds ('377 Patent, col. 1:46-55).

Key Claims at a Glance

  • The complaint asserts "one or more claims" of the '377 patent (Compl. ¶31). Independent claim 1 is representative of the apparatus.
  • Claim 1 (Apparatus) Elements:
    • A housing
    • A cup support mounted to the housing
    • A liquid dispenser to direct liquid into a cup
    • "Grinding means" for grinding a frozen substance in the cup
    • "Aeration means" for incorporating air into the ground substance and liquid mixture
  • The complaint does not explicitly reserve the right to assert dependent claims for this patent.

U.S. Patent No. 7,144,150 - Rinseable Splash Shield And Method Of Use (Issued Dec. 5, 2006)

The Invention Explained

  • Problem Addressed: During the high-speed blending process described in the '377 patent, product can splash out of the cup, creating a mess and sanitation issues ('150 Patent, col. 1:49-52). Additionally, the interaction between the moving blade and the viscous product can create an upward lifting force on the cup, potentially unseating it from its holder ('150 Patent, col. 4:9-24).
  • The Patented Solution: The patent describes a splash shield that is positioned over the cup's opening during mixing. After the cycle, the machine automatically separates the shield from the cup and rinses it with nozzles, preparing it for the next use without manual cleaning ('150 Patent, Abstract). In a key embodiment, the splash shield is weighted (e.g., a 5 lb. cast stainless steel lid) so its mass is sufficient to counteract any upward lifting forces, ensuring the cup remains securely seated in its holder throughout the mixing process ('150 Patent, col. 3:5-29).
  • Technical Importance: This automated, in-place cleaning system enhanced food safety and reduced labor, while the weighted shield design improved the reliability of the blending operation in a self-service context.

Key Claims at a Glance

  • The complaint asserts "one or more claims" of the '150 patent (Compl. ¶36). Independent claim 1 is representative of the method.
  • Claim 1 (Method) Elements:
    • Providing a vessel with contents and a mixing machine with a holder, mixing element, splash shield, and nozzle.
    • After mixing with the splash shield covering the opening, separating the splash shield and the vessel.
    • Directing rinsing fluid onto the splash shield using the nozzle.
    • Shielding the access location from the rinsing fluid.
  • The complaint does not explicitly reserve the right to assert dependent claims for this patent.

U.S. Patent No. 7,520,658 - Rinseable Splash Shield And Method Of Use (Issued April 21, 2009)

  • Technology Synopsis: This patent is part of the same family as the ’150 patent and is also directed to a splash shield for a mixing machine. The invention focuses on a splash shield with sufficient mass to restrain the vessel within its holder against upward forces generated during the mixing process, thereby preventing the vessel from becoming unseated (’658 Patent, Abstract; col. 2:14-22).
  • Asserted Claims: The complaint alleges infringement of "one or more claims" ('658 Compl. ¶43).
  • Accused Features: The complaint alleges that the blenders made by Hamilton Beach embody the patented invention, which includes a weighted splash shield or equivalent feature that keeps the cup in place during blending (Compl. ¶26, ¶43).

U.S. Patent No. 7,520,662 - Rinseable Splash Shield And Method Of Use (Issued April 21, 2009)

  • Technology Synopsis: Also in the same family as the '150 patent, this invention focuses on the method and apparatus for automatically rinsing the splash shield. It describes a system with a rinse chamber, nozzles (including potentially upward- and downward-facing nozzles), and barriers to isolate the rinsing process from the user access area, and specifically claims the use of hot rinsing fluid to improve sanitation (’662 Patent, Abstract; col. 6:6-7).
  • Asserted Claims: The complaint alleges infringement of "one or more claims" (’662 Compl. ¶50).
  • Accused Features: The complaint alleges that the Hamilton Beach blenders practice the patented automated sanitation and rinsing methods (Compl. ¶26, ¶50).

III. The Accused Instrumentality

Product Identification

  • The accused instrumentalities are the "Shake Shop Express" kiosks, which include blending machines manufactured by Hamilton Beach and distributed by Hershey Creamery, along with the frozen milkshake products sold for use therewith (Compl. ¶25, ¶28).

Functionality and Market Context

  • The complaint alleges the accused kiosks function in a manner that directly competes with Plaintiff's business, offering self-service blended milkshakes in retail locations (Compl. ¶25). A side-by-side photograph provided in the complaint shows the accused "Shake Shop Express" kiosk, which, like the plaintiff's product, features a blender unit situated atop a merchandizing freezer containing sealed cups of product (Compl. ¶28, Ex. 8). The complaint alleges these blenders perform the patented blending functions from the ’377 patent and the automated sanitation functions from the '150, '658, and ’662 patents (Compl. ¶26).

IV. Analysis of Infringement Allegations

'377 Patent Infringement Allegations

| Claim Element (from Independent Claim 1) | Alleged Infringing Functionality | Complaint Citation | Patent Citation |
|:---------------------------------------------|:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |:------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |:---------------------|:-------------------|
| An apparatus for making frozen drinks from a frozen substance frozen into a cup, comprising: a housing; | The overall body and structure of the accused "Shake Shop Express" blending machine. The side-by-side photo provided as Exhibit 8 depicts the housing of the accused blender (Compl. ¶28, Ex. 8). | ¶31 | col. 4:2-6 |
| a cup support mounted to the housing; | The mechanism on the accused blender that holds the cup of frozen product during the blending cycle. | ¶31 | col. 4:5-6 |
| a liquid dispenser having an outlet positioned to direct liquid into a cup positioned in the cup support; | The complaint alleges the accused blenders practice the patented blending invention, which requires the addition of liquid, such as milk, to the frozen substance during the blending process. | ¶26 | col. 4:11-15 |
| grinding means for... grinding the frozen substance to form a ground substance; and | The rotating blade and associated drive motor within the accused blender that are lowered into the cup to break up the frozen block of ingredients. | ¶26 | col. 4:41-49 |
| aeration means for... causing air to be incorporated into a mixture of the ground substance... | The design of the rotating blade in the accused blender, which the complaint alleges performs the patented function of whipping air into the mixture to create the desired texture and volume. The ’377 patent teaches this can be done via specific wave-like structures on the blade (’377 Patent, col. 7:36-49). | ¶26 | col. 2:2-12 |

  • Identified Points of Contention:
    • Technical Questions: The complaint alleges the accused blenders perform the claimed "grinding" and "aeration" functions, but provides no detail on the specific structure or operation of the accused machine's internal components. A central factual question will be whether the accused blade assembly has the specific structures (e.g., waves, cutouts, depressed regions) described in the '377 patent specification as performing the aeration function, or their equivalents.
    • Scope Questions: The term "aeration means" is a means-plus-function limitation. Its scope will be limited to the corresponding structures disclosed in the specification and their equivalents. The dispute will likely center on whether the accused blender's blade design is structurally equivalent to the specific blade designs disclosed in the '377 patent.

'150 Patent Infringement Allegations

Claim Element (from Independent Claim 1) Alleged Infringing Functionality Complaint Citation Patent Citation
providing a vessel containing contents to be mixed, the vessel including an opening; The pre-packaged, sealed cups containing frozen milkshake ingredients that are sold by Hershey Creamery for use in the accused "Shake Shop Express" kiosk (Compl. ¶27). ¶36 col. 2:40-43
further providing a mixing machine having a holder... a rotatable mixing element... a splash shield positionable over the opening... and a nozzle oriented towards the splash shield; The complete "Shake Shop Express" blender, which the complaint alleges contains all of these components as part of its automated sanitation system (Compl. ¶26). ¶26, ¶36 col. 3:11-39
after mixing... separating the splash shield and the vessel; and The alleged automated operation of the accused blender, whereby upon completion of a mixing cycle, the cup is lowered away from a splash shield component. ¶26 col. 4:30-39
directing rinsing fluid onto the splash shield using the nozzle while shielding the access location from the rinsing fluid. The complaint alleges the accused blenders practice the patented "blender sanitation inventions," which includes an automated, enclosed rinsing cycle for the splash shield component (Compl. ¶26). ¶26 col. 4:40-50
  • Identified Points of Contention:
    • Technical Questions: The primary point of contention will be factual: does the accused "Shake Shop Express" blender possess an automated, in-place rinsing system for a splash shield? The complaint alleges that it practices the "blender sanitation inventions" but provides no specific evidence, such as photographs or technical descriptions, of any rinsing nozzles, an enclosed rinse chamber, or an automated cleaning cycle.
    • Scope Questions: If the accused device has some form of cover, its properties will be scrutinized. Does that cover function as the claimed "splash shield," which the patent describes as being potentially weighted and separable from the mixing shaft? The existence and function of this specific component in the accused device will be a critical issue.

V. Key Claim Terms for Construction

  • Term: "aeration means" (from '377 Patent)

    • Context and Importance: This is a means-plus-function term under 35 U.S.C. § 112(f). Its construction is critical because infringement requires the accused device to perform the identical function of incorporating air using a structure that is the same as, or equivalent to, the specific structures disclosed in the patent. The dispute will hinge on the structural comparison between the patent's disclosed blade and the accused blender's blade.
    • Intrinsic Evidence for Interpretation: The scope of this term is defined by the structures disclosed in the patent to perform the function. Practitioners will note that the specification provides significant detail, describing a blade with "waves 122" and "cutouts 128" that are specifically designed to "increase the whipping effect" and create "turbulent eddies" ('377 Patent, col. 7:36-49). This detailed disclosure provides a basis for a potentially narrow construction limited to blades with these specific features or their close equivalents.

  • Term: "splash shield" (from '150, '658, '662 Patents)

    • Context and Importance: The definition of this term is central to all three "sanitation" patents. The infringement analysis depends on whether the accused blender has a component that qualifies as a "splash shield" under the proper construction. Practitioners may focus on this term because its interpretation could either limit the claims to a very specific type of weighted, self-rinsing lid or allow them to read on a wider variety of covers.
    • Evidence for a Broader Interpretation: The term itself is straightforward. A party might argue it should be given its plain and ordinary meaning: any component that shields the surrounding area from splashes.
    • Evidence for a Narrower Interpretation: The specification repeatedly discusses the shield in a specific context. It is described as being potentially "a cast stainless steel lid having a weight of approximately 5 lbs" ('150 Patent, col. 4:25-27) and having sufficient mass to overcome upward lifting forces to keep the cup "seated in the holder" ('150 Patent, col. 2:18-24). This language could support a narrower construction requiring the shield to be a distinct, separable, and potentially weighted component that performs the dual functions of splash prevention and cup retention.

VI. Other Allegations

  • Indirect Infringement: The complaint alleges that Hamilton Beach induces infringement of the '150, '658, and '662 patents. This is based on allegations that Hamilton Beach provides operating instructions to Hershey Creamery and other retailers for use of the accused blenders, knowing that such use constitutes infringement (Compl. ¶37, ¶44, ¶51).
  • Willful Infringement: The complaint alleges that Hamilton Beach's infringement of the '150, '658, and '662 patents has been willful. The factual basis for this allegation is Defendant Hamilton Beach’s prior license to these three patents, which it terminated on August 2, 2011 (Compl. ¶24, ¶38, ¶45, ¶52). This history is alleged to establish that Hamilton Beach had actual, pre-suit knowledge of the patents and their applicability to the technology.

VII. Analyst’s Conclusion: Key Questions for the Case

  1. A central evidentiary question will be one of technical reality: Does the accused "Shake Shop Express" blender actually contain the automated "sanitation" features claimed in the '150, '658, and '662 patents? The complaint's allegations of an in-place, nozzle-based rinsing system for a splash shield will require significant factual proof, as no direct evidence of such a system is presented in the initial pleading.

  2. A core issue will be one of structural and functional equivalence: Assuming the accused blender has a mixing blade, does its design incorporate structures equivalent to the specific "aeration means" (e.g., waves and cutouts) disclosed in the '377 patent? Similarly, does it employ a "splash shield" that meets the patents' description of a potentially heavy, separable component that actively retains the cup in its holder?

  3. The case presents a critical question of objective reasonableness for willfulness: Given that Hamilton Beach formerly licensed the technology covered by three of the asserted patents, if infringement of those patents is found, the focus will shift to whether Hamilton Beach developed a good-faith, objectively reasonable belief that its new, competing product did not infringe. The prior license creates a high bar for the defendant to clear to defeat a finding of willfulness.