DCT

2:18-cv-11842

Twin Star Intl Inc v. Dimplex North America Ltd

Log In

I. Executive Summary and Procedural Information

  • Parties & Counsel:
  • Case Identification: 2:18-cv-11842, E.D. Mich., 06/08/2018
  • Venue Allegations: Plaintiff alleges venue is proper because Defendant, a foreign corporation, is subject to personal jurisdiction in the district. The complaint notes that Defendant previously sued Plaintiff in the same district, thereby availing itself of the forum, and upon information and belief, has a regular and established place of business in the district.
  • Core Dispute: Plaintiff alleges that Defendant’s electric fireplace products infringe three patents related to creating multi-color simulated flame effects, displaying control settings, and providing distinct controls for flame and heat functions.
  • Technical Context: The technology at issue concerns improvements to electric fireplaces, focusing on user interface design and creating more aesthetically realistic visual flame effects that mimic the color gradients of a real fire.
  • Key Procedural History: The complaint states that the parties engaged in discussions to resolve the dispute beginning "since at least March 13, 2017," more than a year prior to the filing of the lawsuit. The complaint also notes that Defendant previously initiated a patent infringement lawsuit against Plaintiff in the same judicial district.

Case Timeline

Date Event
2009-10-06 Priority Date for ’010 and ’596 Patents
2010-12-20 Priority Date for ’439 Patent
2014-06-03 ’439 Patent Issued
2016-10-04 ’010 Patent Issued
2016-10-25 ’596 Patent Issued
2017-03-13 Pre-suit Negotiations Allegedly Began
2018-06-08 Complaint Filing Date

II. Technology and Patent(s)-in-Suit Analysis

U.S. Patent No. 8,739,439 - MULTI-COLOR SIMULATED FLAME SYSTEM FOR ELECTRIC FIREPLACES, issued June 3, 2014

The Invention Explained

  • Problem Addressed: The patent’s background section states that conventional electric fireplaces often lack a visually realistic flame effect because they fail to replicate the "multi-color gradient that can be seen in real flames" (ʼ439 Patent, col. 1:24-28).
  • The Patented Solution: The invention uses a two-path lighting system to create a more realistic flame. A first light-emitting device projects a first color (e.g., orange/yellow) onto a rotating, reflective spindle, which reflects the "dancing" light onto an upper portion of a projection screen. A second light-emitting device projects a second color (e.g., blue/violet) directly onto a lower, overlapping portion of the screen, creating a gradient effect from the base of the "flame" to its tips (ʼ439 Patent, Abstract; col. 2:36-53).
  • Technical Importance: This approach sought to improve the aesthetic realism of electric fireplaces by simulating both the motion and the complex color layering characteristic of actual combustion (ʼ439 Patent, col. 1:56-62).

Key Claims at a Glance

  • The complaint asserts independent claim 1 (Compl. ¶21).
  • The essential elements of independent claim 1 include:
    • A projection surface with at least two adjacent and overlapping light projection areas.
    • A first light-emitting device that projects reflected light of a first color onto the first projection area.
    • A second light-emitting device that projects light of a second color directly onto the second projection area.
    • The two light sources are installable behind the projection surface.
    • The two light sources create multi-chromatic flame effects simulating a fuel source, with specific color ranges recited for each.
    • The light from the two sources overlaps to produce a gradient of colors, shades, and hues that imitates a real flame.

U.S. Patent No. 9,459,010 - FUNCTION INDICATOR SYSTEM FOR ELECTRIC FIREPLACE, issued October 4, 2016

The Invention Explained

  • Problem Addressed: The patent identifies two deficiencies in prior electric fireplaces: the lack of a "visually attractive display means for displaying control settings" and the absence of devices for "signaling visually and audibly when a heater or heat source has been disabled" for safety (ʼ010 Patent, col. 1:33-47).
  • The Patented Solution: The invention describes a system that projects a "non-video visual status display" (e.g., icons or text for temperature or timer settings) onto the main fireplace screen. Critically, it also claims a "heater disabling feature" that is "separate and distinct" from the primary "heater power control feature," allowing a user to run the aesthetic flame effect without the heating element being active or even operable (ʼ010 Patent, Abstract; col. 2:40-49).
  • Technical Importance: This technology provides an integrated, modern user interface that is only visible when needed, and introduces a specific safety and convenience feature by decoupling the heat-generation function from the visual flame effect (ʼ010 Patent, col. 2:14-22).

Key Claims at a Glance

  • The complaint asserts independent claim 1 (Compl. ¶32).
  • The essential elements of independent claim 1 include:
    • An electric fireplace with a simulated fuel source and a projection screen.
    • A function indicator module that creates a "non-video visual status display" using projected light.
    • A controller connected to the function indicator module.
    • A "heater power control feature" to turn the heater on and off.
    • A "heater disabling feature" that is "separate and distinct" from the power control feature, which allows for selective operation of the flame effect without the heater.
    • A power source and a light source for the flame effect.

U.S. Patent No. 9,476,596 - FUNCTION INDICATOR SYSTEM FOR ELECTRIC FIREPLACE, issued October 25, 2016

  • Patent Identification: U.S. Patent No. 9,476,596, “FUNCTION INDICATOR SYSTEM FOR ELECTRIC FIREPLACE,” issued October 25, 2016 (Compl. ¶12).
  • Technology Synopsis: Related to the ’010 Patent, this invention focuses on a system for displaying control settings on an electric fireplace’s screen. The system uses a function indicator module with lights to project a "non-video visual status display" onto the screen, with a key aspect being that the module and display are "substantially hidden from view" when the indicator lights are not illuminated, preserving the fireplace aesthetic (ʼ596 Patent, Abstract).
  • Asserted Claims: The complaint asserts independent claim 1 (Compl. ¶43).
  • Accused Features: The accused "Infringing Function Indicator System" is alleged to infringe by projecting control settings that are visible when active but fade from view when inactive (Compl. ¶15, 21, 43).

III. The Accused Instrumentality

  • Product Identification: The Dimplex Multi-Fire XD® Electric Firebox (Model # PF2325HL) (Compl. ¶14).
  • Functionality and Market Context: The Accused Product is an electric fireplace insert. The complaint subdivides its functionality into three accused systems:
    • An "Infringing Lighting System" alleged to create a multi-color flame effect using multiple light sources (Compl. ¶15).
    • An "Infringing Heat Control System" alleged to allow separate control over the heating function, including a feature to disable the heater while flame effects continue (Compl. ¶15, 32). An annotated user manual excerpt is provided to show the operation of the heater disabling feature (Compl. p. 16).
    • An "Infringing Function Indicator System" alleged to create a "Floating Display" of control settings that are projected onto the fireplace screen (Compl. ¶15, 43). The complaint includes a marketing image highlighting this "Floating Display" (Compl. p. 11).
    • The complaint alleges the product is marketed with claims of "customizable flame and light effects" to provide the look of "realistic gas and wood flames" (Compl. p. 9).

IV. Analysis of Infringement Allegations

’439 Patent Infringement Allegations

| Claim Element (from Independent Claim 1) | Alleged Infringing Functionality - | Complaint Citation | Patent Citation |
|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |:-----------------------|:--------------------|
| a projection surface comprising a first light projection area and at least a second light projection area, wherein the first light projection area is adjacent to and overlaps the at least second light projection area; - | ¶21, p. 6 | col. 5:30-38 |
| a first light-emitting device for projecting reflected light of a first color onto the first light projection area of the projection surface; - | A first LED projects reflected light (from a spindle) of an "about red to an about orange hue" onto the upper part of the flame screen. - | ¶21, p. 7 | col. 5:47-54 |
| at least a second light-emitting device for projecting light of a second color directly onto the at least second light projection area of the projection surface; - | A second LED projects light of an "about blue to about violet" hue onto the lower part of the flame screen. An annotated photograph shows the internal components of the Accused Product, identifying "Blue lights," "Flame lights," and a "Flame Spindle" behind the flame screen (Compl. p. 7). | ¶21, p. 7 | col. 5:61-65 |
| wherein... the first light-emitting device creates a multi-chromatic flame effect... with visible wavelengths ranging between about yellow and about red and the second... creates a multi-chromatic flame effect... with visible wavelengths ranging between about violet and about blue; | The first and second LEDs are alleged to create multi-chromatic flame effects simulating a fuel source with wavelengths corresponding to the claimed ranges. - | ¶21, p. 8 | col. 8:3-11 |
| wherein the light of the first color overlaps the light of the second color to produce the multi-chromatic flame effect appearing with a gradient of colors, shades, and hues to imitate a real flame. - | The first and second colors are alleged to overlap to create a multi-chromatic flame effect with a gradient of colors. A marketing image is provided to support the claim of realistic, customizable flame effects (Compl. p. 9). - | ¶21, p. 9 | col. 8:12-17 |

  • Identified Points of Contention:
    • Scope Questions: The complaint alleges the first LED emits an "about red to an about orange hue" (Compl. p. 7), while the claim it is mapped to recites a range "between about yellow and about red." This raises the question of whether the accused color range falls within the claimed color range.
    • Technical Questions: Infringement of claim 1 hinges on the distinct paths of light: the first being reflected and the second being direct. The complaint alleges this configuration but provides only static photographs. The case may require more detailed evidence to establish whether the light from the second LED projects "directly" onto the screen without any intermediate reflection or interaction with the spindle, as required by the claim.

’010 Patent Infringement Allegations

Claim Element (from Independent Claim 1) - Alleged Infringing Functionality - Complaint Citation Patent Citation
an electric fireplace comprising a simulated fuel source and a projection screen; - The Accused Product is an electric fireplace with a simulated fuel source and a projection screen. - ¶32, p. 12 col. 5:25-30
a function indicator module for creating a non-video visual status display... wherein the non-video visual status display comprises projected light; - The Accused Product has a function indicator module that creates a "Floating Display" of control settings on the projection screen using projected light. ¶32, p. 13 col. 5:17-25
a controller communicatively connected to the function indicator module; - The Accused Product includes a remote control that is wirelessly connected to the function indicator module. A diagram of the remote control illustrates various functions (Compl. p. 14). ¶32, p. 14 col. 5:22-24
a heater power control feature to turn on and off power to the heater; - The Accused Product has a "Heat On/Off" button on its remote control that serves as a heater power control feature. - ¶32, p. 15 col. 2:40-44
a heater disabling feature operable to selectively create the simulated flame effect without operating the heater, the heater disabling feature being separate and distinct from the heater power control feature; The Accused Product allegedly has a heater disabling feature, activated by holding the power button for 10 seconds, which is separate from the standard heater on/off button. ¶32, p. 16 col. 2:44-49
  • Identified Points of Contention:
    • Scope Questions: A central dispute may arise over the meaning of "separate and distinct." The complaint alleges the "heater disabling feature" (a 10-second button hold) is separate from the "heater power control feature" (a standard button press). A court will have to determine if a different operational mode of the same physical button qualifies as a "separate and distinct" feature under the patent's claims.
    • Technical Questions: Does the alleged "heater disabling feature" operate through a different control pathway or logic than the standard "heater power control feature"? The infringement analysis may depend on the underlying software and hardware architecture, which is not detailed in the complaint.

V. Key Claim Terms for Construction

  • Term: "projecting... directly" (’439 Patent, Claim 1)

    • Context and Importance: This term is critical for distinguishing the path of the second light source from the first, which projects reflected light. Infringement requires proof of two different light paths. Practitioners may focus on this term because the entire theory of operation in the claim relies on this structural and functional difference.
    • Intrinsic Evidence for a Broader Interpretation: The patent does not provide an explicit definition, which could support an argument for its plain and ordinary meaning: a straight, uninterrupted path from the light source to the projection surface.
    • Intrinsic Evidence for a Narrower Interpretation: The specification explains that the second light-emitting device is positioned so that its light "does not strike the reflective spindle" (ʼ439 Patent, col. 5:62-63). This could support an interpretation where "directly" means specifically "without striking the spindle," potentially allowing for other incidental reflections not contemplated by the patent.

  • Term: "separate and distinct" (’010 Patent, Claim 1)

    • Context and Importance: The viability of the infringement claim for the ’010 patent hinges on whether the accused heater disabling function is "separate and distinct" from its regular power control. If they are construed as two modes of a single feature, the claim may not be met.
    • Intrinsic evidence for a Broader Interpretation: The patent describes the heater disabling feature as potentially being a "concealed feature of a control feature of the electric fireplace other than the heater power control feature" (ʼ010 Patent, col. 2:47-49). This language suggests the features can be functionally and operationally distinct even if not tied to completely separate hardware.
    • Intrinsic evidence for a Narrower Interpretation: The patent’s emphasis on a separate feature could be argued to require more than a different user input (e.g., long press vs. short press) on the same button. A party could argue it requires a discrete control element or a fundamentally different software module, not just a conditional logic branch.

VI. Other Allegations

  • Indirect Infringement: The complaint alleges both induced and contributory infringement for all three patents. Inducement is based on allegations that Dimplex provides instructions, user manuals, and videos that intentionally encourage end-users to operate the Accused Product in an infringing manner (Compl. ¶25, 36, 47). Contributory infringement is based on the allegation that the accused systems have no substantial non-infringing uses (Compl. ¶27, 38, 49).
  • Willful Infringement: Willfulness is alleged for all three patents. The complaint establishes a basis for pre-suit knowledge by alleging that discussions between the parties regarding the infringing systems have been ongoing since "at least March 13, 2017" (Compl. ¶18, 28, 39, 50).

VII. Analyst’s Conclusion: Key Questions for the Case

  1. A core issue will be one of claim construction: can the phrase "separate and distinct feature," as used in the ’010 patent, be construed to cover a function that is accessed by a different user input (e.g., a long press) on the same physical button as another claimed feature?

  2. A key evidentiary question will be one of operational mechanics: can Plaintiff demonstrate that the Accused Product’s lighting system utilizes the specific two-path light projection mechanism required by the ’439 patent—one path being reflected off a spindle and the other being projected directly onto the screen?

  3. The allegation of pre-suit negotiations raises a crucial question regarding willfulness: if infringement is found, will the court determine that Defendant’s continued sales after being put on notice of the patents-in-suit constitute willful conduct sufficient to justify enhanced damages?