John A. Artz

Krista S. Schwartz

Mark L. Whitaker

Jeffrey A. Miller

Matthew Freimuth

A. Max Olson

Akira Irie

Daniel D. Quick

Hui Zhao

Teresa T. Pham

Richard A. Kamprath

David Sochia

Susan M. McKeever

Patrick G. Seyferth

Ashley N. Moore

Jason Wejnert

Alexandra F. Easley

William D. Ellerman

Casey Shomaker

Robyn Williams

Christopher Clayton

Kristin Leveille

Behind-the-scenes chip design process challenged: Socionext faces suit over patents for efficient `engineering change order` implementation & `dummy fill` placement.

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Gershwin A. Drain	01/10/23 - 06/27/23	29%
Terrence G. Berg	01/05/23 - 01/10/23	20%

Name	Ratings
McKool Smith	L5 E
David Sochia	L4 D
Richard A. Kamprath	L4 E
Ashley N. Moore	L3 C
Alexandra F. Easley	L1 C
Casey Shomaker	L1 D
William D. Ellerman	L1 D
Kristin Leveille	-- -- --
Bush Seyferth & Paige PLLC	L3 C
Susan M. McKeever	L1 B
Patrick G. Seyferth	L1 B
Devlin Law Firm	L3 C
Christopher Clayton	L1 C
Jason Wejnert	L1 D
Robyn Williams	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
A. Max Olson	L2 A
Akira Irie	L2 A
Mark L. Whitaker	L2 D
Hui Zhao	-- -- --
Teresa T. Pham	-- -- --
Arnold & Porter Kaye Scholer LLP	L4 A
Jeffrey A. Miller	L2 C
Dickinson Wright PLLC	L3 D
John A. Artz	L5 E
Daniel D. Quick	-- -- --
Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP	L3 E
Krista S. Schwartz	L5 A
Matthew Freimuth	-- -- --

2:22-cv-12749

Bell Semiconductor LLC v. Socionext America Inc