DCT

2:07-cv-00229

Minerva Industries Inc v. Motorola Inc

General

Filed

06/06/07

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (12/22/11)

Patent Owner

Operating Company (L)

PACER

2:07-cv-00229

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
David Folsom	02/17/11 - 12/22/11	40%
T. John Ward	10/11/07 - 02/17/11	53%
Donald E. Walter	10/11/07 - 10/11/07	--
T. John Ward	10/04/07 - 10/11/07	53%

MagistrateCharles C. Everingham, IV, John D. Love

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Minerva Industries Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5 A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5 A
Collin M. Maloney	L4 A
Jones Day	L5 A
Walter Jones, Jr.	L5 A
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5 E
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5 E
Sidney C. Capshaw, III	L5 E
Daymon J. Rambin	L5 E
Nancy C. Abernathy	L4 E
Jessica Lea Hannah	L2 E
Jedidiah J. Rollins	-- -- --
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5 E
Claire A. Henry	L4 E
Spangler Law LongviewLocal	L4 A
Andrew W. Spangler	L5 B
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4 E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L4 D
Russ August & Kabat	L2 C
Alexander C. D. Giza	L5 B
Adam S. Hoffman	L5 B
Andrew D. Weiss	L4 A
Stanley H. Thompson, Jr.	L4 C
Marc A. Fenster	L4 D
Irene Y. Lee	L3 D
Larry C. Russ	-- -- --
Robert E. Satterthwaite	-- -- --
David R. Gabor	-- -- --
Eric B. Carlson	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Motorola Inc	L4 A
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5 A
Sony Corp	L5 A
Nokia Mobile Phones Inc	L5 A
Nokia Inc	L5 A
Hewlett-Packard Inc	L5 A
Hewlett-Packard Co	L5 A
Verizon Wireless Services LLC	L5 A
Verizon Communications Inc	L5 A
TracFone Wireless Inc	L5 A
Cellco Partnership Inc	L5 A
Alltel Wireless Of Texarkana LLC	L5 A
Alltel Corp	L5 A
Alltel Communications Wireless Inc	L5 A
Alltel Communication Inc	L5 A
Samsung Telecommunications America LLP	L5 E
Samsung Telecommunications America LLC	L5 E
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5 E
Samsung America Inc	L5 E
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5 E
LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA Inc	L5 E
Motorola Wuhan Mobility Technologies Communication Co Ltd	L4 A
Dobson Cellular Systems Inc	L4 A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L4 A
Sanyo North America Corp	L4 A
Virgin Mobile USA LP	L4 B
T-Mobile USA Inc	L4 B
Suncom Wireless Operating Co LLC	L4 B
Sprint Wireless Broadband Co LLC	L4 B
Sprint Spectrum LP	L4 B
Sprint Nextel Corp	L4 B
Nextel West Corp	L4 B
Nextel South Corp	L4 B
Nextel of Texas Inc	L4 B
Nextel of New York Inc	L4 B
Nextel of California Inc	L4 B
Nextel Communications Of Mid Atlantic Inc	L4 B
Metropcs Inc	L4 B
MetroPCS Communications Inc	L4 B
Helio LLC	L4 B
Helio Inc	L4 B
Boost Mobile LLC	L4 B
Utstarcom Inc	L3 A
High Tech Computer Corp	L3 A
Qwest Corp	L3 C
Kyocera Wireless Corp	L2 A
Palm Inc	L2 A
Research In Motion Corp	L2 B
HTC Corp	L2 B
HTC America Inc	L2 B
Pantech Wireless LLC NPE	L1 A
Pantech Wireless Inc NPE	L1 A
Virgin Mobil USA LLC	L1 B

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Dickstein Shapiro LLP	L5 A
Jeffrey K. Sherwood	L3 A
Frank C. Cimino, Jr.	L3 A
Andy Tindel	-- -- --
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
John F. Bufe	L4 B
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
Harold J. McElhinny	L4 E
Alison M. Tucher	L2 E
David E. Melaugh	-- -- --
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5 A
Paul B. Keller	L4 A
Christine E. Duh	L2 B
Anne Jin Lee	L2 B
Mark G. Matuschak	-- -- --
Mark D. Flanagan	-- -- --
Peter Dichiara	-- -- --
Crowell & Moring LLP	L5 A
Andrew M. Riddles	L2 B
Bruce D. Derenzi	L2 E
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5 A
Peter J. Chassman	-- -- --
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5 E
Melissa R. Smith	L5 E
Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.	-- -- --
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5 E
Robert C. Bunt	L5 E
Charles Ainsworth	L5 E
Cooley LLP	L4 E
Kyle D. Chen	L5 A
Warren S. Heit	L3 D
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L5 E
Roth Law FirmLocal	L3 A
Amanda A. Abraham	L3 A
Carl R. Roth	L3 A
Carl R RothLocal	L3 A
Brendan C. Roth	L3 A
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3 A
Fred I. Williams	L3 A
Eric J. Klein	L3 A
Todd E. Landis	L2 B
Jin-Suk Park	L2 B
Steven M. Zager	L2 D
David C. Vondle	-- -- --
Ashley R. Adams	-- -- --
Thompson & Knight LLP	L3 B
Jane P. Brandt	L5 C
Richard L. Wynne	L4 A
Bruce S. Sostek	L4 C
Matthew P. Harper	-- -- --
David C. Schulte	-- -- --
Holland & Knight LLP	L3 B
Benjamin M. Stern	L3 C
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP	L3 B
Daniel A. Devito	L4 D
Marti A. Johnson	L3 D
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L3 C
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	-- -- --
Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP	L3 E
Josh A. Krevitt	L5 D
Steven M. Geiszler	-- -- --
John L. Labarre	-- -- --
Kathleen B. McNamee	-- -- --
Stevens LoveLocal	L2 A
Scott E. Stevens	L3 A
Haltom & DoanLocal	L2 C
Darby V. Doan	L1 D
James N. Haltom	L1 E
Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP	L2 D
Timothy J. Vezeau	L5 A
Michael A. Dorfman	L4 D
Breighanne A. Eggert	L3 C
Rachel M. Vorbeck	-- -- --
McAfee & Taft	L1 B
Michael J. Labrie	L4 A
Charles L. McLawhorn, III	L4 B
Michael D. McClintock	L3 B
John A. Kenney	L3 C
HC Park & Associates	L1 C
Wayne M. Helge	L2 A
Hae-Chan Park	-- -- --
Highbury ChapmanLocal	L1 D
Brain S. Seal	L1 D
Hitchcock Evert LLPLocal	-- -- --
John M. Cone	-- -- --
Turner Davis & GeraldLocal	-- -- --
David H. Smith	-- -- --
Lee Hong Degerman Kang & Waimey	-- -- --
Larry R. Schmadeka	-- -- --
Thomas D FortenberryLocal	-- -- --
Thomas D. Fortenberry	-- -- --

No Attorneys