DCT

2:09-cv-00274

PalTalk Holdings Inc v. Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc

General

Filed

09/14/09

Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (10/25/11)

Patent Owner

Operating Company (L)

PACER

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
David Folsom	09/17/09 - 10/25/11	43%
T. John Ward	09/17/09 - 09/17/09	53%

MagistrateCharles C. Everingham, IV, Caroline M. Craven

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
PalTalk Holdings Inc	L1 B

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5 A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5 A
Deborah J. Race	L5 E
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5 D
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5 D
Sidney C. Capshaw, III	L5 E
Daymon J. Rambin	L5 E
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5 E
Jack W. Hill	L5 A
Thomas J. Ward, Jr.	L5 A
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5 E
Robert C. Bunt	L5 E
Charles Ainsworth	L5 E
Dorsey & Whitney LLP	L4 A
Michael F. Heim	L4 C
Douglas R. Wilson	-- -- --
Niraj P. Patel	-- -- --
Susman Godfrey LLP	L3 E
Max L. Tribble	L5 E
Brooke A. M. Taylor	L4 B
Kalpana Srinivasan	L3 B
Matthew Behncke	-- -- --
Amira Mae El-Hakam	-- -- --
David M. Peterson	-- -- --
Heim Payne & Chorush LLP	L1 D
Micah J. Howe	L3 E
Nathan J. Davis	-- -- --
Cooper Byron EsquireLocal	-- -- --
Byron W. Cooper	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc	L5 A
Sony Online Entertainment LLC	L5 A
Sony Corp	L5 A
Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC	L5 A
Blizzard Entertainment Inc	L5 A
Activision Publishing Inc	L5 A
Activision Blizzard Inc	L5 A
Turbine Inc	L3 A
Jagex Ltd	L2 D
Ncsoft Corp	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
Vincent J. Belusko	L5 A
Brian F. McMahon	L4 C
Scott C. Moore	L4 C
Jason J. Lee	-- -- --
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 C
Allen F. Gardner	L5 E
John F. Bufe	L4 B
Ropes & Gray LLP	L5 A
Jesse J. Jenner	L5 E
Gene W. Lee	L3 B
Brian P. Biddinger	L2 C
Tal Kedem	-- -- --
Matthew R. Clements	-- -- --
Hanyong Lee	-- -- --
David S. Chun	-- -- --
McKool Smith	L5 A
Samuel F. Baxter	L5 A
Jason D. Cassady	L5 A
Jennifer L. Truelove	-- -- --
Irell & Manella LLP	L4 B
Morgan Chu	L5 A
Peter E. Gratzinger	L3 B
Ellisen S. Turner	L3 E
Eric B. Hanson	-- -- --
Andrew P. Nguyen	-- -- --
Blake B. Greene	-- -- --
Elliot Brown	-- -- --
Jorge L. Fernandez	-- -- --
Latham & Watkins LLP	L4 B
Ron E. Shulman	L5 E
Robert Steinberg	L4 A
Franklin D. Kang	L3 E
Renny F. Hwang	L2 E
Charles P. Courtenay	-- -- --
Jeff Myung	-- -- --
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4 C
Lawrence A. Phillips	L3 E
Clyde M. Siebman	L3 E
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4 E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L4 E
Cooley LLP	L4 E
Thomas J. Friel, Jr.	L5 A
Richard S. Sanders	L3 E
Christopher C. Campbell	L2 A
Heather A. Faltin	L1 C
Banner & Witcoff LTD	L3 A
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L5 B
Timothy C. Meece	L4 A
Christopher B. Roth	L4 D
Audra C. Eidem Heinze	-- -- --
Ross A. Dannenberg	-- -- --
Young Pickett & LeeLocal	L2 A
John M. Pickett	L2 C
Damon M. Young	L2 E
WYLY Rommel PLLCLocal	-- -- --
Sean F. Rommel	-- -- --

No Attorneys