DCT

2:10-cv-00574

Geotag Inc v. Western Union Co

General

Filed

12/18/10

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

PACER

2:10-cv-00574

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
James R. Gilstrap	01/04/12 - 07/01/14	35%
Michael H. Schneider, Sr.	02/23/12 - 01/02/14	31%
David Folsom	12/20/10 - 02/23/12	40%
T. John Ward	08/01/11 - 08/08/11	53%

MagistrateCaroline M. Craven, Roy S. Payne, Charles C. Everingham, IV

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Geotag Inc NPE	L1 C
iCIMS Inc	L2 D
Albertsons LLC	L1 E
Albertsons Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5 A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5 A
Deborah J. Race	L4 D
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4 A
Michael C. Smith	-- -- --
Tadlock Law FirmLocal	L2 D
Charles C. Tadlock	L2 B
Keith B. Smiley	L1 D
Bell Nunnally & MartinLocal	L2 E
Jeffrey A. Tinker	-- -- --
Buether Joe & Carpenter	L2 E
Eric W. Buether	L5 E
Brian A. Carpenter	L5 E
Christopher M. Joe	L5 E
Niknaz Bukovcan	L2 B
Monica N. Tavakoli	L2 E
Mark D. Perantie	L2 E
Niky R. Bagley	-- -- --
Charles van CleefLocal	L1 C
Charles van Cleef	L1 C
Dealy Zimmermann Clark Malouf & MacFarlaneLocal	L1 D
Mark J. Zimmermann	L1 D
Turner Dealy Zimmermann & ClarkLocal	L1 D
Thomas C. Clark	-- -- --
Ni Law Firm PLLC	L1 D
Stevenson Moore, V	L2 D
Timothy T. Wang	L2 D
Ni Wang Associates PLLC	L1 D
Hao Ni	L4 B
Preti Flaherty Beliveau Pachios	L1 D
Denise C. Lane	-- -- --
Mount & Stoelker	L1 E
Daniel S. Mount	L3 D
Kevin M. Pasquinelli	L2 C
William H. Stewart	-- -- --
Reese Marketos LLPLocal	-- -- --
Joel W. Reese	-- -- --
Adam C. Sanderson	-- -- --
Spangler Law FirmLocal	-- -- --
Andrew W. Spangler	L4 E
David W Collins IP LawLocal	-- -- --
David R. Bennett	L1 D
Anderson & CunninghamLocal	-- -- --
David K. Anderson	-- -- --
Gardner Haas PLLCLocal	-- -- --
Eric P. Haas	-- -- --
Michael S. Gardner	-- -- --
Malouf & Nockels LLPLocal	-- -- --
Jonathan A. Nockels	-- -- --
Jeremy C. Martin	-- -- --
Stephen F. Malouf	-- -- --
Michael Tobolowsky	-- -- --
Spickard LawLocal	-- -- --
Todd S. Spickard	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Western Union Holdings Inc	-- -- --
Western Union Financial Services Inc	-- -- --
Western Union Co	-- -- --
Whole Foods Market Services Inc	L4 A
Whole Foods Market Inc	L4 A
Quest Diagnostics Inc	L3 A
Dollar General Corp	L3 A
Home Depot USA Inc	L3 C
Pacific Biosciences of California Inc	L2 A
OMX Inc	L2 A
OfficeMax Inc	L2 A
Office Depot LLC	L2 A
Office Depot Inc	L2 A
Ticketmaster LLC	L2 A
Live Nation Worldwide Inc	L2 A
Live Nation Entertainment Inc	L2 A
Lowes Companies Inc	L2 A
Lowe S Cos Inc	L2 A
CVS Pharmacy Inc	L2 A
Taser Intl Inc	L2 B
Walgreens Corp	L2 B
Walgreen Co	L2 B
Bath Body Works Direct Inc	L2 B
Bath & Body Works LLC	L2 B
Bath & Body Works Direct Inc	L2 B
Fifth Third Bank	L2 B
Fifth Third Bancorp	L2 B
doing Business Asfifth Third Bank	L2 B
Family Dollar Stores Inc	L2 B
Homer TLC Inc	L2 E
Scotts Miracle Gro Co	L1 B
Scotts Co LLC	L1 B
Therma-Tru Corp	L1 B
Therma Tru Corp	L1 B
Burt S Bees Inc	L1 B
New Albertson S Inc	L1 C
MapQuest Inc	L1 D
Laboratory Corp	L1 D
Suntrust Investment Services Inc	L1 D
Suntrust Banks Inc	L1 D
Suntrust Bank	L1 D
New Albertsons Inc	L1 E
Whole Foods Market IP LP	-- -- --
doing Business Asticketmasters LLC	-- -- --
Swan Corp	-- -- --
Mattress Firm Inc	-- -- --
Mattress Giant Corp	-- -- --
Steelcase Inc	-- -- --
Southern States Cooperative	-- -- --
Pip Inc	-- -- --
Piggy Wiggly LLC	-- -- --
Olson + Co Inc	-- -- --
Medela LLC	-- -- --
Medela Inc	-- -- --
Winn Dixie Stores Inc	-- -- --
Pacific Bioscience Laboratories Inc	-- -- --
Learning Express Inc	-- -- --
Jim's Formal Wear Co	-- -- --
Jim S Formal Wear Co	-- -- --
Jelly Belly Candy Co	-- -- --
Home Depot Inc	-- -- --
Heb Grocery Co LP	-- -- --
HEB Grocery Co	-- -- --
Famly Dollar Inc	-- -- --
Piggly Wiggly LLC	-- -- --
Burts Bees Inc	-- -- --
Build A Bear Workshop Inc	-- -- --
Brookshire Brothers Ltd	-- -- --
Best Maid Products Inc	-- -- --
Beech Nut Nutrition Corp	-- -- --
Albertson S Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
K&L Gates	L5 A
Michael J. Bettinger	L5 A
Jennifer K. Ayers	L4 B
Irene I. Yang	L3 A
Steven G. Schortgen	L3 A
Christy V. La Pierre	L2 C
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Allen F. Gardner	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
John F. Bufe	L4 A
Daniel A. Noteware, Jr.	L1 B
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5 A
Thomas M. Melsheimer	L5 A
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5 A
Matias Ferrario	L2 A
Leslie T. Grab	-- -- --
Gardere Wynne Sewell LLP	L5 A
William D. Dunn	-- -- --
Hunton & Williams LLP	L5 A
Brian Buroker	L4 A
Michael A. Oakes	L4 A
Ozzie Farres	-- -- --
Edward F. Fernandes	-- -- --
Christopher M. First	-- -- --
Fran R. Aden	-- -- --
Fulbright & Jaworski LLP	L5 A
Michael C. Barrett	L4 E
Mark T. Garrett	L2 A
Sarah R. Holland	L2 E
Charles S. Baker	-- -- --
Michael A. Swartzendruber	-- -- --
Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP	L5 A
Brandon J. Karam	-- -- --
Fish & Richardson	L5 B
Neil J. McNabnay	L5 A
David J. Healey	L5 E
Jane J. Du	L3 D
Michael A. Bittner	L3 E
Taj J. Clayton	L2 B
Wasif H. Qureshi	L2 D
Kathleen Harris	-- -- --
James E. Youngblood	-- -- --
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L5 B
Melissa R. Smith	L5 A
Andrew T. Gorham	L3 B
Bobby Lamb	-- -- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 B
John M. Guaragna	L5 E
Henning Schmidt	L4 A
Brian K. Erickson	L4 E
Jeffrey L. Johnson	L3 B
Robert W. Kantner	L3 B
Erik Fuehrer	L3 C
Andrew P. Valentine	L3 C
Nicholas G. Papastavros	L3 D
Jesse Hindman	L2 D
Ryan W. Cobb	-- -- --
Amy P. Mohan	-- -- --
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5 B
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5 B
Daymon J. Rambin	L4 E
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5 D
Charles Ainsworth	L5 D
Alston & Bird LLP	L4 A
Jason W. Cook	L5 E
Kamran Jivani	L4 B
Robert L. Lee	L4 D
Frank G. Smith, III	L4 E
Alan Lee Whitehurst	L3 A
Derek S. Neilson	L1 C
Adam Swain	-- -- --
Brinks Hofer Gilson & Lione	L4 A
Laura A. Lydigsen	L3 E
William H. Frankel	L2 C
Cozen Oconnor	L4 A
Martin B. Pavane	L5 A
Lisa A. Ferrari	L2 C
Kendall R. Kelly	-- -- --
Christopher J. Hanlon	-- -- --
Findlay CraftLocal	L4 A
Eric H. Findlay	L5 A
Roger B. Craft	-- -- --
Michael D. Findlay	-- -- --
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L4 A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5 A
M. Dru Montgomery	L4 A
Cohen Pontani Lieberman & Pavane	L4 A
Mher Hartoonian	L2 B
Craig C. Crafton	-- -- --
Baker Botts LLP	L4 B
Scott F. Partridge	L4 E
Elizabeth D. Flannery	L2 E
Jennifer P. Adams	L1 C
William Rothwell	-- -- --
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4 B
Debra E. Gunter	L3 A
Herbert A. Yarbrough, III	L3 D
Wildman Harrold Allen & Dixon LLP	L4 B
John S. Letchinger	L3 E
Edward T. Walker	L2 A
Douglas S. Rupert	-- -- --
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L4 E
Nixon Peabody LLP	L3 B
Russell J. Genet	L3 E
Jodi R. Wine	L2 B
Jason C. Kravitz	L2 D
Ramey & FlockLocal	L3 B
Deron R. Dacus	L4 A
Shannon M. Dacus	L3 A
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3 B
Clayton C. James	L2 B
Srecko Vidmar	L2 D
Williams Morgan & AmersonLocal	L3 B
Danny L. Williams	L3 A
Christopher N. Cravey	L2 A
Michael A. Benefield	L2 A
Brian K. Buss	L1 B
Terry D. Morgan	L1 D
David K. Wooten	L1 D
Haynes & Boone LLP	L3 B
Phillip B. Philbin	L5 A
Charles M. Jones, II	-- -- --
Dykema Gossett LLP	L3 C
Allan J. Sternstein	L4 C
David G. Henry	L3 C
Timothy K. Sendek	L2 C
Baker & McKenzie LLP	L3 D
Nathan A. Engels	L2 E
Brian C. McCormack	L2 E
Mark D. Taylor	-- -- --
Andrew C. Moreton	-- -- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L3 E
Edward J. Benz, III	L4 E
Robin L. McGrath	L2 E
McGinnis Lochridge LLPLocal	L2 B
Travis C. Barton	L1 D
Kane Russell Coleman & LoganLocal	L2 B
Zach T. Mayer	-- -- --
Coghlan Crowson LLPLocal	L2 B
Stayton L. Worthington	L1 D
Seyforth Shaw	L2 C
Matthew A. Werber	L2 B
Seyfarth Shaw LLP	L2 C
Daniel J. Schwartz	L2 D
Christensen O'Connor Johnson Kindness PLLC	L2 D
Michael N. Zachary	L2 A
John D. Denkenberger	L2 E
Kelley Drye & Warren LLP	L2 E
Robert G. Graham	L2 C
Fredrikson & Byron PA	L2 E
Lora M. Friedemann	-- -- --
Ted C. Koshiol	-- -- --
Mercy Carter Tidwell LLPLocal	L2 E
John R. Mercy	-- -- --
Evans DixonLocal	L1 C
Don V. Kelly	L1 C
Benjamin M. Fletcher	-- -- --
Eugene P. Schmittgens, Jr.	-- -- --
Greensfelder Hemker & Gale	L1 D
Mary Ann L. Wymore	-- -- --
J. Andrew Walkup	-- -- --
Lewis Rice	L1 D
Michael J. Hickey	L3 E
Ward Zinna	L1 E
John F. Ward	L4 E
Michael J. Zinna	L3 C
Matthew C. Berntsen	L2 C
Patrick R. Colsher	L2 D
Gruber Hurst Johansen & Hail LLPLocal	-- -- --
Anthony J. Magee	-- -- --
Michael K. Hurst	-- -- --
Boutin Jones Inc	-- -- --
Chris Gibson	-- -- --
Maralee Eriksen	-- -- --
Glast Phillips & MurrayLocal	-- -- --
Richard E. Young	-- -- --
Martin Disiere Jefferson & WisdomLocal	-- -- --
Douglas H. Elliott	L1 D
Dale Jefferson	L1 D
Fletcher Farley Shipman & Salinas LLPLocal	-- -- --
Douglas D. Fletcher	-- -- --
Keith A. Robb	-- -- --
Chamberlain Hrdlicka White Williams & MartinLocal	-- -- --
Randall K. Hawes	-- -- --

No Attorneys