DCT

6:09-cv-00274

Soverain Software LLC v. JC Penney Corp Inc

General

Filed

06/25/09

Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (05/29/15)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER

6:09-cv-00274

Appeals

12-1649

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Robert W. Schroeder, III	04/29/15 - 09/21/15	36%
Leonard E. Davis	06/25/09 - 04/29/15	35%

MagistrateJohn D. Love, Charles C. Everingham, IV

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Soverain Software LLC NPE	L1 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5 A
Edward J. Defranco	L5 A
Robert B. Wilson	L4 E
Michael C. Smith	L3 D
James M. Glass	L2 A
Carlos A. Rodriguez	L2 B
Anastasia M. Fernands	L2 C
Peter G. Hawkins	L2 C
Stephen Smith	-- -- --
Kate E. Cassidy	-- -- --
Keith H. Forst	-- -- --
Latham & Watkins LLP	L4 A
David A. Nelson	-- -- --
Michael F. Harte	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
JC Penney Corp	L3 B
JC Penney Co Inc	L3 B
QVC Inc	L3 A
Garnet Hill Inc	L3 A
Cornerstone Brands Inc	L3 A
Ballard Designs Inc	L3 A
HSN LP	L3 A
HSN Inc	L3 A
HSN Improvements LLC	L3 A
Victorias Secret Direct Brand Management LLC	L2 B
Avon Products Inc	L1 B
Amway Corp	L1 B
Shutterfly LLC	L1 C
Shutterfly Inc	L1 C
Territory Ahead Inc	-- -- --
Smith & Noble LLC	-- -- --
Bidzcom Inc	-- -- --
Vistaprint USA Inc	-- -- --
Vistaprint Ltd	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Cooley LLP	L5 A
Thomas J. Friel, Jr.	L5 B
Richard S. Sanders	L3 E
Matthew P. Gubiotti	L2 E
Heather A. Faltin	L1 B
Christopher Campbell	-- -- --
Alana Martinez	-- -- --
Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP	L5 A
Winstol D. Carter, Jr.	L4 A
David J. Levy	L3 A
James A. Glenn, Jr.	L2 E
Preetam Shingavi	L1 B
Gary M. Gex	-- -- --
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
Allen F. Gardner	L5 A
Douglas Ray McSwane, Jr.	L3 A
E. Glenn Thames, Jr.	L3 C
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
Minn Chung	L2 A
Andrew E. Monach	L2 A
Matthew A. Chivvis	L2 B
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5 A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5 A
Deborah J. Race	L4 D
Greenberg Traurig LLP	L5 B
Mary-Olga Lovett	L5 C
Michael A. Nicodema	L5 E
Barry J. Schindler	L4 B
Dwayne L. Mason	L4 E
Kimberly A. Warshawsky	L3 E
Gaston Kroub	L2 C
Diane K. Lettelleir	-- -- --
Brinks Hofer Gilson & Lione	L4 A
James R. Sobieraj	L3 A
Laura B. Miller	L2 B
Scott A. Timmerman	L1 D
James A. Collins	-- -- --
Findlay CraftLocal	L4 B
Roger B. Craft	L4 E
Yarbrough Wilcox PLLCLocal	L4 B
Herbert A. Yarbrough, III	L4 A
Debra E. Gunter	L3 A
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L4 B
Robert C. Bunt	L5 A
Charles Ainsworth	L5 A
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3 B
John M. Jackson	L3 A
Robert P. Latham	L2 A
Sara K. Borrelli	L1 B
Ramey & FlockLocal	L3 B
Deron R. Dacus	L4 A
Shannon M. Dacus	L3 A
Seyfarth Shaw LLP	L2 C
Joseph R. Lanser	L2 A
Michael R. Levinson	L2 A
Misty C. Blair	-- -- --
Seyforth Shaw	L2 C
Matthew A. Werber	L2 A
Dechert LLP	L2 C
Robert D. Rhoad	L4 C
Jeffrey B. Plies	L3 C
Robert W. Ashbrook	L2 B
Robert L. Masterson	L2 C
Daniel B. Epstein	L1 D
Christopher S. Ruhland	-- -- --
Ward Zinna	L1 D
Michael J. Zinna	L4 B
John F. Ward	L4 D
David S. Nir	L2 C
Michael G. Gabriel	L1 C
Ryan S. McPhee	-- -- --
Seldon & ScillieriLocal	L1 D
Robert A. Seldon	L1 D
John A. Scillieri	L1 D
Leggat HaganLocal	-- -- --
Bonnie J. Leggat	-- -- --

No Attorneys