DCT
6:13-cv-00447
Smartflash LLC v. Apple Inc
General
Filed
05/29/13
Cause of ActionWillful Patent Infringement
SectorSemicond., Optic
Status
Closed (01/11/19)
Patent Owner
NPE (L)
PACER
6:13-cv-00447
CourtE.D. Texas
| Judge | Period | PO Win Rate | 
|---|---|---|
| 12/22/14 - 11/24/20 | 33% | |
| 05/30/13 - 12/22/14 | 31% | 
MagistrateKatie K. Mitchell, John D. Love
Plaintiff
Attorney
| Name | Ratings | 
|---|---|
| L5 E | |
| L5 E | |
| L5 E | |
| L2 E | |
| L2 E | |
| L5 B | |
| L5 E | |
| L5 E | |
| L3 A | |
| L3 E | |
| L3 E | |
| L2 A | |
| L2 C | |
| L2 D | |
| L2 E | |
| Aaron M Panner PLLCLocal | -- -- -- | 
| -- -- -- | 
No Attorneys
Defendant
Party
| Name | Ratings | 
|---|---|
| L5 A | |
| -- -- -- | |
| -- -- -- | |
| -- -- -- | 
No Parties
Attorney
| Name | Ratings | 
|---|---|
| L5 A | |
| L5 A | |
| Gillam & Smith LLPLocal | L5 A | 
| L5 A | |
| -- -- -- | |
| L5 A | |
| L3 A | |
| L2 B | |
| L4 A | |
| L4 A | |
| L2 B | |
| L4 B | |
| L4 C | |
| L3 A | |
| L3 C | |
| L2 C | |
| L2 C | |
| -- -- -- | |
| -- -- -- | |
| L4 B | |
| L4 A | |
| L2 A | |
| L2 C | |
| L2 C | |
| L1 A | |
| L1 B | |
| L1 D | |
| L1 D | |
| -- -- -- | |
| -- -- -- | |
| L4 D | |
| L5 A | |
| L5 A | |
| L3 D | |
| L4 E | |
| L2 B | |
| L2 D | |
| L1 B | 
No Attorneys