PTAB

CBM2015-00131

Apple Inc v. Smartflash LLC

General

Filed

05/08/15

Institution11/16/15

FWD11/10/16

Close11/10/16

StatusFinal Written Decision

OutcomeUnpatentable

USPTOCBM2015-00131

Appeals

Administrative Patent Judges

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Gregg I Anderson	500+	68%	75%
Jennifer S Bisk	500+	63%	89%
Jeremy M Plenzler	300+	63%	80%
Jeremy M Plenzler	300+	63%	80%
Matthew R Clements	400+	72%	89%
Rama G Elluru	400+	62%	84%

Petitioner

Party

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ropes & Gray LLP	L5 A
J. Steven Baughman	L5 A
Gabrielle E. Higgins	L1 C

No Attorneys

Respondent

Party

Name	Ratings
Smartflash LLC NPE	L4 E
Smartflash Technologies Ltd NPE	L4 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Davidson Berquist Jackson & Gowdey LLP	L5 E
Michael R. Casey	L5 E

No Attorneys