Pantech Co Ltd v. Cellular Communications Equipment LLC

Alan A. Wright

NEC, HTC & LG challenge a mobile security patent: Multiple grounds of anticipation & obviousness cited against 14 claims on app message interception.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Gregg I Anderson	500+	68%	75%
Jennifer S Bisk	500+	63%	88%
Robert J Weinschenk	600+	54%	85%

Name	Ratings
Pantech Co Ltd NPE	L3 C
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5 B
LG Electronics Inc	L5 B
HTC America Inc	L4 D
HTC Corp	L4 D
ZTE Inc	L4 E
ZTE USA Inc	L4 E
Pantech Wireless Inc NPE	L3 C
NEC Mobile Communications Ltd	L2 C
NEC Casio Mobile Communications Ltd	L2 C
NEC Corp	L2 C

Name	Ratings
Mayer Brown LLP	L5 A
Robert G. Pluta	L3 B
Amanda S. Bonner	L1 C
Baldine B. Paul	-- -- --
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L5 A
Richard W. Thill	L1 C
Steven J. Moore	-- -- --
HC Park & Associates	L1 D
Alan A. Wright	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Cellular Communications Equipment LLC NPE	L4 A
Nokia Siemens Networks Oy	L1 B

Name	Ratings
Burns & Levinson LLP	L3 E
Jerry Cohen	-- -- --
Martin Ferraro LLP	L2 E
Amedo Ferraro	L4 B
Nelson Bumgardner Albritton	L1 E
Barry Bumgardner	L1 B