PTAB

IPR2015-00846

Lenovo United States Inc v. Personal Audio LLC

General
Filed
03/06/15
Institution09/17/15
FWD09/09/16
Close09/09/16
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomeUnpatentable
USPTOIPR2015-00846
Appeals
17-1162
17-2110
17-2111
Administrative Patent Judges
Judge
Cases
Inst. Rate
FWD Inv. Rate
Brian P Murphy200+58%89%
David C McKone1000+76%85%
David C McKone1000+76%85%
Mitchell G Weatherly500+73%85%
Mitchell G Weatherly500+73%85%
Petitioner
Party
Name
Ratings
Lenovo United States Inc 
L4
B
Google Inc 
L5
D
Lenovo Holding Co Inc 
L4
B
Lenovo Group Ltd 
L4
B
Barnes & Noble Inc 
L2
D
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Blakely Sokoloff Taylor Zafman
L1
C
Daniel M. De Vos
L2
E
Nicholson De Vos Webster & Elliott LLP
L1
E
Matthew N. Nicholson
L1
C
No Attorneys
Respondent
Party
Name
Ratings
Personal Audio LLC NPE
L3
B
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Dinovo Price Ellwanger & Hardy LLP
L4
E
Minghui Yang
L3
C
Gregory S. Donahue
L2
E
No Attorneys