PTAB

IPR2016-00390

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v. Elm 3DS Innovations LLC

General
Filed
12/28/15
Institution07/01/16
FWD06/23/17
Close06/23/17
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomePatentable
USPTOIPR2016-00390
Appeals
17-2474
17-2478
Administrative Patent Judges
Judge
Cases
Inst. Rate
FWD Inv. Rate
Barbara A Benoit300+71%84%
Barbara A Benoit300+71%84%
Frances L Ippolito400+62%81%
Glenn J Perry200+53%73%
Petitioner
Party
Name
Ratings
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 
L5
A
Micron Technology Inc 
L4
A
SK Hynix Inc 
L3
A
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
K&L Gates
L5
A
Jason A. Engel
L5
E
Benjamin E. Weed
--
--
--
Paul Hastings LLP
L5
B
Naveen Modi
L5
A
Allan M. Soobert
L2
C
Phillip Citroen
--
--
--
O Melveny & Myers
L4
E
John Kappos
L3
A
Xin-Yi Zhou
--
--
--
No Attorneys
Respondent
Party
Name
Ratings
Elm 3DS Innovations LLC NPE
L3
E
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Robins Kaplan LLP
L5
E
Cyrus A. Morton
L5
E
Kelsey McElveen
L2
C
Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky & Popeo
L4
E
William Meunier
L5
A
Carmichael IP
L2
E
James T. Carmichael
L1
C
No Attorneys