Cisco Systems Inc v. TQ Delta LLC

David L. McCombs

Cisco targets DSL phase scrambling patent: Shively & Stopler prior art cited for all 30 claims as obvious over reducing peak-to-average power ratio.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Kalyan K Deshpande	500+	52%	91%
Matthew R Clements	400+	72%	89%
Sally C Medley	700+	65%	92%
Trevor M Jefferson	500+	61%	88%

Name	Ratings
Cisco Systems Inc	L5 A
Verizon Services Corp	L5 B
Cox Communications Inc	L4 A
Comcast Cable Communications LLC	L4 A
Arris Group Inc	L4 A
Dish Network LLC	L4 B
Time Warner Cable Enterprisesss LLC	L3 A