PTAB

IPR2016-01520

Apple Inc v. Personalized Media Communications LLC

General
Filed
07/30/16
Institution02/16/17
FWD09/08/22
Close09/08/22
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomeUnpatentable
USPTOIPR2016-01520
Appeals
20-1198
23-1165
23-1166
23-1168
Administrative Patent Judges
Judge
Cases
Inst. Rate
FWD Inv. Rate
Georgianna W Braden600+66%87%
Karl D Easthom1000+78%88%
Kevin F Turner800+70%76%
Trenton A Ward200+59%84%
Petitioner
Party
Name
Ratings
Apple Inc 
L5
A
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Kirkland & Ellis LLP
L5
A
Alan M. Rabinowitz
L3
C
Marcus E. Sernel
L3
E
Joel R. Merkin
L1
C
Gregory S. Arovas
--
--
--
Eugene Goryunov
--
--
--
No Attorneys
Respondent
Party
Name
Ratings
Personalized Media Communications LLC NPE
L4
E
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Goodwin Procter LLP
L5
E
Stephen Schreiner
L5
E
Jennifer A. Albert
L5
E
Douglas Kline
L3
D
Sara Fink
--
--
--
Personalized Media Communications
--
--
--
Thomas J. Scott
L3
C
No Attorneys