Apple Inc v. Evolved Wireless LLC

Stephen S. Korniczky

Apple & Microsoft challenge RACH preamble patent: Panasonic & Chu prior art cited for obviousness of 10 claims in mobile communications.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Christopher L Crumbley	500+	62%	75%
Peter P Chen	200+	50%	93%
Terrence W McMillin	400+	58%	83%
William V Saindon	600+	69%	85%

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5 A
Microsoft Mobile Inc	L5 A
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5 A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5 A
HTC America Inc	L5 A
Microsoft Mobile Oy	L5 A
HTC Corp	L5 A
Microsoft Corp	L5 A
ZTE USA Inc	L5 E

Name	Ratings
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5 A
Kevin P. B. Johnson	L5 A
Todd M. Briggs	L1 B
James M. Glass	L1 C
John T. McKee	-- -- --
Fish & Richardson	L5 A
W. Karl Renner	L5 A
David Holt	L2 B
Roberto J. Devoto	-- -- --
McDermott Will & Emery LLP	L4 A
Charles M. McMahon	L2 B
Hersh H. Mehta	-- -- --
Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP	L4 C
Stephen S. Korniczky	L4 E

Name	Ratings
Evolved Wireless LLC NPE	L2 E
LG Ltd	L5 C