Multi Packaging Solutions Inc v. CPI Card Group Minnesota Inc

Mark D. Rowland

Gabrielle E. Higgins

Michael Scheer

Pejman Sharifi

Louis L. Campbell

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Secure card package patent challenged as obvious: Willard, Maak & Jones prior art cited against 30 claims for using printed adhesive on clay-coated board.

CPI Card Group Minnesota Inc

CPI Card Group Colorado Inc

Multi Packaging Solutions Inc

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

IPR2017-01650 | Multi Packaging Solutions Inc v. CPI Card Group Minnesota Inc | Ex Parte

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Christopher M Kaiser	400+	56%	69%
Grace K Obermann	600+	55%	66%
Jeffrey W Abraham	400+	59%	85%

Name	Ratings
Ropes & Gray LLP	L5 A
Mark D. Rowland	L4 E
Gabrielle E. Higgins	L1 C

Name	Ratings
CPI Card Group Minnesota Inc	L2 C
CPI Card Group Colorado Inc	L2 C

Name	Ratings
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5 A
Pejman Sharifi	-- -- --
Louis L. Campbell	-- -- --
Michael J Scheer	L1 D
Michael Scheer	L2 C