Nichia Corp v. Document Security Systems Inc

Matthew G. Berkowitz

Patrick R. Colsher

Eric S. Lucas

Aldo Noto

James T. Wilson

Wayne M. Helge

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Flip-chip LED packaging patent challenged on obviousness: Lumbard & Ishidu prior art cited against all 14 claims for combining packages with flip-chip LEDs.

Document Security Systems Inc

Nichia Corp

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

IPR2018-00965 | Nichia Corp v. Document Security Systems Inc | Ex Parte

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Brent M Dougal	300+	69%	81%
Sally C Medley	700+	65%	92%
Scott C Moore	300+	72%	80%

Name	Ratings
Allen Overy LLP	L4 E
Matthew G. Berkowitz	L4 B
Patrick R. Colsher	L3 E
Eric S. Lucas	L1 C

Name	Ratings
Davidson Berquist Jackson & Gowdey LLP	L5 E
Wayne M. Helge	L5 D
Aldo Noto	L1 C
James T. Wilson	-- -- --