PTAB

IPR2018-01054

3M Co v. Aptar France Sas

General
Filed
05/10/18
Institution11/08/18
FWD--
Close11/07/19
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomeUnpatentable
USPTOIPR2018-01054
Administrative Patent Judges
Please sign up or log in to access the advanced features of
Ex Parte Professional.
or Log in
Judge
Cases
Inst. Rate
FWD Inv. Rate
Scott A Daniels
500+
50%
50%
Richard H Marschall
500+
50%
50%
Hyun J Jung
500+
50%
50%
Petitioner
Please sign up or log in to access the advanced features of
Ex Parte Professional.
or Log in
Party
Name
Ratings
3M Co 
L4
B
Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp 
L4
A
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
L5
A
Patrick J. Coyne
L5
A
Peter Kinsella
L5
A
Scott E. Holwick
L5
A
Honigman Miller Schwartz Cohn LLP
L5
A
Neal S. Cohen
L5
A
No Attorneys
Respondent
Please sign up or log in to access the advanced features of
Ex Parte Professional.
or Log in
Party
Name
Ratings
Aptar France Sas 
L2
D
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
McKool Smith
L5
A
Patrick J. Coyne
L5
A
No Attorneys