Vanguard Products Group Inc v. InVue Security Products Inc

Anton J. Hopen

Andriy Lytvyn

Tim F. Williams

Trent Kirk

Scott A. Cole

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Merchandise security system patent faces 3 obviousness challenges. Prior art cited for combining intelligent sensor features with adjustable retaining arms.

InVue Security Products Inc

Vanguard Products Group Inc

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

IPR2020-00032 | Vanguard Products Group Inc v. InVue Security Products Inc | Ex Parte

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Barbara A Parvis	700+	59%	83%
Barbara A Parvis	700+	59%	83%
Cynthia M Hardman	100+	71%	70%
Lynne E Pettigrew	600+	63%	86%
Michael R Zecher	700+	61%	88%
Michaela Zecher	20+	88%	77%
Sheila F McShane	500+	72%	88%
Stacey G White	500+	64%	77%

Name	Ratings
Smith & Hopen PA	L3 E
Andriy Lytvyn	L3 D
Anton J. Hopen	L3 D

Name	Ratings
Dority & Manning PA	L2 B
Tim F. Williams	L3 B
Scott A. Cole	L1 D
In Vue Security Products Inc	L1 D
Trent Kirk	L2 C