PTAB

IPR2021-00145

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v. Neonode Smartphone LLC

General
Filed
11/06/20
Institution06/16/21
FWD06/15/22
Close06/15/22
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomeUnpatentable
USPTOIPR2021-00145
Appeals
22-2134
Administrative Patent Judges
Judge
Cases
Inst. Rate
FWD Inv. Rate
Christopher L Ogden300+62%82%
Kara L Szpondowski200+52%80%
Michelle N Ankenbrand200+48%80%
Petitioner
Party
Name
Ratings
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 
L5
A
Apple Inc 
L5
A
Samsung Electronics America Inc 
L5
A
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Fish & Richardson
L5
A
W. Karl Renner
L5
A
David Holt
--
--
--
DLA Piper US LLP
L5
E
James M. Heintz
L5
A
Tiffany C. Miller
--
--
--
No Attorneys
Respondent
Party
Name
Ratings
Neonode Smartphone LLC NPE
L1
D
No Parties
Attorney
Name
Ratings
Sunstein Kann Murphy & Timbers LLP
L3
E
Robert M. Asher
L3
D
Bruce D. Sunstein
--
--
--
Timothy M. Murphy
--
--
--
No Attorneys