PTAB

IPR2021-01212

Siemens Industry Software Inc v. Synopsys Inc

General

Filed

07/13/21

Institution01/13/22

FWD01/11/23

Close01/11/23

StatusFinal Written Decision

OutcomeUnpatentable

USPTOIPR2021-01212

Appeals

Administrative Patent Judges

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
David C McKone	1000+	76%	85%
Frederick C Laney	700+	80%	83%
Jennifer M Chagnon	500+	74%	71%
Karl D Easthom	1000+	78%	88%
Kevin F Turner	800+	70%	76%
Michael T Cygan	200+	75%	83%
Scott C Moore	300+	72%	80%

Petitioner

Party

Name	Ratings
Siemens Industry Software Inc	L4 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Klarquist Sparkman LLP	L4 B
Todd M. Siegel	L5 E
Andrew M. Mason	L4 A

No Attorneys

Respondent

Party

Name	Ratings
Synopsys Inc	L3 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Jones Day	L5 E
Matthew Johnson	L5 A
Joseph M. Sauer	L5 D
David B. Cochran	L4 E
Joshua R. Nightingale	-- -- --
Marlee R. Hartenstein	-- -- --
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3 E
Celine J. Crowson	L2 C

No Attorneys