Google LLC v. EcoFactor Inc

Justin J. Oliver

Matthew A. Smith

Elizabeth A. Laughton

Kristopher Davis

Reza Mirzaie

Philip X. Wang

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Google challenges HVAC efficiency patent: multiple obviousness grounds cite Hildebrand & Spalink art against all 20 claims for monitoring & diagnostics.

ecobee Technologies ULC

Google LLC

Ecofactor Inc

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

IPR2021-01218 | Google LLC v. EcoFactor Inc | Ex Parte

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Jeffrey W Abraham	400+	59%	85%
Scott B Howard	400+	67%	82%
Scott B Howard	400+	67%	82%
Wesley B Derrick	100+	49%	84%
Wesley B Derrick	100+	49%	84%

Name	Ratings
Google LLC	L5 A
ecobee Technologies ULC	L2 B

Name	Ratings
Venable LLP	L5 A
Justin J. Oliver	L4 B
Smith Baluch LLP	L3 B
Matthew A. Smith	L4 B
Elizabeth A. Laughton	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Russ August & Kabat	L5 E
Philip X. Wang	L4 C
Kristopher Davis	-- -- --
Reza Mirzaie	-- -- --