Apple Inc v. SpaceTime3D Inc

W. Karl Renner

Brent K. Yamashita

Erika H. Arner

Matthew Satchwell

Andrew Patrick

Kenneth Darby

Usman Khan

Yanyi Liu

Yinan Liu

Cory Bell

Christopher G. Duerden

Gregory S. Cordrey

Todd E. Fitzsimmons

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

Apple targets a 3D graphical user interface patent: Anthony & Hanggie prior art cited against all 20 claims as obvious over 3D window management tech.

Google LLC

SpaceTime3D Inc

Apple Inc

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

IPR2023-00344 | Apple Inc v. SpaceTime3D Inc | Ex Parte

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
David C McKone	1000+	76%	85%
Frederick C Laney	700+	80%	83%
Hubert C Lorin	100+	56%	91%
Karl D Easthom	1000+	78%	88%
Minn Chung	300+	58%	89%
Sheila F McShane	500+	72%	88%
Stacy Crittenden	10+	75%	100%

Name	Ratings
Apple Inc	L5 A
Google LLC	L5 A

Name	Ratings
Fish & Richardson	L5 A
W. Karl Renner	L5 A
Kenneth Darby	L1 C
Usman Khan	L1 C
Andrew Patrick	-- -- --
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5 A
Erika H. Arner	L5 A
Cory Bell	L5 E
Yanyi Liu	-- -- --
Yinan Liu	-- -- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 E
Matthew Satchwell	L5 B
Brent K. Yamashita	L5 E
Christopher G. Duerden	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell LLP	L2 C
Gregory S. Cordrey	L5 B
Fitzsimmons IP Law	L1 E
Todd E. Fitzsimmons	L2 D