LG Electronics Inc v. SpaceTime3D Inc

W. Karl Renner

Google & LG challenge a 3D GUI patent: Anthony & Hanggie prior art cited for all 20 claims as obvious over combining 3D timelines with 2D app views.

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
David C McKone	1000+	76%	85%
David C McKone	1000+	76%	85%
Frederick C Laney	700+	80%	83%
Hubert C Lorin	100+	56%	91%
Hubert C Lorin	100+	56%	91%
Karl D Easthom	1000+	78%	88%
Minn Chung	300+	58%	89%
Sheila F McShane	500+	72%	88%

Name	Ratings
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5 A
Erika H. Arner	L5 A
Cory Bell	L5 E
Yanyi Liu	-- -- --
Yinan Liu	-- -- --
Fish & Richardson	L5 A
W. Karl Renner	L5 A
Andrew Patrick	L3 E
Kenneth Darby	L1 C
Usman Khan	L1 C
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 E
Brent K. Yamashita	L5 E
Matthew Satchwell	L3 C
Christopher G. Duerden	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell LLP	L2 C
Gregory S. Cordrey	L5 B
Fitzsimmons IP Law	L1 E
Todd E. Fitzsimmons	L2 D