PTAB

IPR2023-01254

Colgate Palmolive Co v. Noble Innovations NC LLC

General

Filed

07/26/23

Institution02/01/24

FWD01/23/25

Close01/23/25

StatusFinal Written Decision - Appealed

OutcomeUnpatentable

USPTOIPR2023-01254

Appeals

Administrative Patent Judges

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Michaela Valek	100+	59%	74%
Ryan H Flax	200+	79%	72%
Timothy G Majors	100+	79%	59%

Petitioner

Party

Name	Ratings
Colgate-Palmolive Co Inc	L2 B

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Munck Wilson Mandala LLP	L2 E
Daniel E. Venglarik	L4 E
Amy E. Lavalle	L1 D
Keith Harden	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Respondent

Party

Name	Ratings
Noble Innovations NC LLC	L2 D

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
DNL Zito	L2 E
Benjamin C. Deming	L3 A
Joseph J. Zito	L3 E
Whitestone Law	L1 D
Kendal M. Sheets	-- -- --

No Attorneys