LG Energy Solution Ltd v. Molecular Rebar Design LLC

W. Karl Renner

Timothy W. Riffe

Andrew R. Sommer

Heath Briggs

Julie P. Bookbinder

Trenton A. Ward

Hyun Jin In

Gretchen Devries

Kathryn Albanese

Gregory L. Porter

Steven L. Wood

James H. Hall

Stephen D. Zinda

Prosecution History analysis

Examiner Search analysis

Invalidity Framework analysis

LG Energy Solution targets a carbon nanotube battery patent, arguing 16 claims are obvious over Ohata & Kavan prior art on oxidized CNTs & ion doping.

Black Diamond Structures LLC

LG Energy Solution Ltd

Molecular Rebar Design LLC

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd

Samsung Electronics America Inc

Last Docket Entry Date

Total Docket Entries

IPR2024-01013 | LG Energy Solution Ltd v. Molecular Rebar Design LLC | Ex Parte

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Judge	Cases	Inst. Rate	FWD Inv. Rate
Jeffrey W Abraham	400+	59%	85%
Jon B Tornquist	500+	59%	81%
Julia Heaney	100+	80%	79%

Name	Ratings
LG Energy Solution Ltd	L5 A
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd	L5 A
Samsung Electronics America Inc	L5 A

Name	Ratings
Greenberg Traurig LLP	L5 A
Heath Briggs	L5 A
Andrew R. Sommer	L5 E
Trenton A. Ward	L5 E
Julie P. Bookbinder	-- -- --
Kathryn Albanese	-- -- --
Fish & Richardson	L5 A
W. Karl Renner	L5 A
Timothy W. Riffe	L5 A
Hyun Jin In	L4 E
Gretchen Devries	-- -- --

Name	Ratings
Molecular Rebar Design LLC	L4 E
Black Diamond Structures LLC	L4 E

Name	Ratings
Hunton & Williams LLP	L5 E
Gregory L. Porter	L1 C
Steven L. Wood	-- -- --
Cabello Hall Zinda	L2 E
Stephen D. Zinda	L5 A
James H. Hall	L5 E