PTAB
PGR2021-00098
VMware Inc v. Cirba IP Inc
General
Institution12/10/21
FWD12/07/22
Close12/07/22
StatusFinal Written Decision
OutcomeUnpatentable
USPTOPGR2021-00098
Appeals
Administrative Patent Judges
Judge | Cases | Inst. Rate | FWD Inv. Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| David C McKone | 1000+ | 76% | 85% |
| Justin T Arbes | 700+ | 57% | 84% |
| Russell E Cass | 300+ | 72% | 91% |
| Russell E Cass | 300+ | 72% | 91% |
| Stacy B Margolies | 200+ | 78% | 79% |
Petitioner
Attorney
Name | Ratings |
|---|---|
L5 E | |
L5 E | |
L5 E | |
L2 A | |
L1 C | |
L1 D |
No Attorneys
Respondent
Attorney
Name | Ratings |
|---|---|
L1 E | |
L1 D | |
L1 D | |
-- -- -- | |
-- -- -- |
No Attorneys