DCT

3:09-cv-02535

SPH America LLC v. Acer Inc

General

Filed

11/09/09

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

PACER

3:09-cv-02535

CourtS.D. California

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Cathy Ann Bencivengo	02/15/12 - 04/15/13	23%
John A. Houston	12/03/09 - 02/15/12	50%
Leonie M. Brinkema	07/07/09 - 12/03/09	30%

MagistrateAnthony J. Battaglia, Mitchell D. Dembin, Barbara L. Major, Karen S. Crawford, Ruben B. Brooks

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
SPH America LLC NPE	L1 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Finnegan Henderson Farabow Garrett & Dunner LLP	L5 B
E. Robert Yoches	L4 B
Christopher S. Schultz	L3 C
Ming-Tao Yang	L3 D
Edward J. Naidich	L2 B
Lily Lim	L2 C
Troy E. Grabow	L2 D
Aaron J. Capron	-- -- --
Minjae Kang	-- -- --
Rajeev Gupta	-- -- --
Christian & Barton LLPLocal	L2 E
Rowland B. Hill, IV	L4 E
Nichole B. Vanderslice	L3 E
Henry I. Willett, III	L2 E
David B. Lacy	L2 E
Echelon Law Group	L1 E
Andrew Choung	L3 E
Kyongtaek K. Mun	L2 E
Tae H. Kim	L2 E
John Dubiansky	-- -- --
Robert G. Litts	-- -- --
Haeyong Lee	-- -- --
Seung Ho Lee	-- -- --
Patterson & Sheridan LLP	L1 E
Allison H. Goddard	L1 C
Carlineo Spicer & KeeLocal	-- -- --
Daniel S. Carlineo	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Acer Inc	L4 E
Acer America Corp	L4 E
Fujitsu America Inc	L3 E
Sierra Wireless America Inc	L2 A
Casio America Inc	L1 C
Sony-Ericsson Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5 A
Sony Mobile Communications USA Inc	L5 A
Sony Mobile Communications Ab	L5 A
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications Ab	L5 A
Sony Electronics Inc	L5 A
Sony Corp	L5 A
Hewlett-Packard Co	L5 A
Dell Inc	L5 A
Apple Inc	L5 A
Panasonic Electronic Devices Corp	L4 A
Panasonic Corp	L4 A
Nokia Inc	L4 A
Nokia Corp	L4 A
Motorola Solutions Inc	L4 A
Motorola Inc	L4 A
Amazon.com Inc	L4 A
Motorola Mobility LLC	L4 B
Motorola Mobility Inc	L4 B
Lenovo United States Inc	L4 B
Lenovo Holding Co Inc	L4 B
Personal Communications Devices LLC	L3 A
Personal Communications Devices Holdings LLC	L3 A
Fujitsu Ltd	L3 E
Palm Inc	L2 A
Sierra Wireless Inc	L2 A
General Dynamics Corp	L2 B
ZTE USA Inc	L1 B
ZTE Corp	L1 B
Futurewei Technologies Inc	L1 B
Novatel Wireless Technology Inc	L1 C
Novatel Wireless Solutions Inc	L1 C
Novatel Wireless Inc	L1 C
Utstarcom Inc	-- -- --
Option Wireless USA Inc	-- -- --
Option NV	-- -- --
Option Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Howrey LLP	L5 A
Henry C. Bunsow	L5 A
Gregory S. Cordrey	L4 D
Martha K. Gooding	L3 D
Christopher L. Kelley	L2 A
Gregory J. Commins, Jr.	L2 B
Andrew R. Sommer	L2 B
Don F. Livornese	L2 D
Victoria Q. Smith	-- -- --
K&L Gates	L5 A
Michael J. Bettinger	L5 A
Holly Hogan	L3 B
Timothy P. Walker	L3 D
Eric C. Rusnak	L2 B
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5 A
Michael L. Brody	L4 A
Jonathan E. Retsky	L4 B
Gail J. Standish	L4 C
Peter E. Perkowski	L3 C
David P. Enzminger	L3 D
David Dalke	L2 E
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5 A
Eric Huang	L3 A
Alexander Rudis	L3 B
Jordan R. Jaffe	-- -- --
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
David C. Doyle	L5 A
John P. Corrado	L3 A
Christian G. Andreu-Von Euw	-- -- --
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5 A
Mark D. Selwyn	L5 B
Melanie D. Coates	-- -- --
Perkins Coie LLP	L5 A
N. Thane Bauz	-- -- --
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5 A
Michael J. Lockerby	-- -- --
Jones Day	L5 A
Blaney Harper	L4 B
Jose L. Patino	L3 E
Tara L. Renee Zurawski	L2 E
Walter D. Kelley, Jr.	L2 E
Douglas Pearson	-- -- --
Greenberg Traurig LLP	L5 C
James W. Soong	L3 C
E. Patrick Ellisen	L3 D
Alice Chu	-- -- --
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP	L4 A
Kaiwen Tseng	L4 D
Preston Burton	-- -- --
Alston & Bird LLP	L4 B
Michael J. Newton	L5 A
Rachel M. Capoccia	L3 A
Patrick J. Flinn	L3 B
Stacey G. White	L3 B
Ross R. Barton	L2 A
Ryan W. Koppelman	L1 B
Derek S. Neilson	L1 C
Venable LLP	L4 B
Michael W. Robinson	-- -- --
Goodwin Procter LLP	L4 C
Steven J. Moore	L5 A
Kurt M. Kjelland	L2 B
David E. Kleinfeld	L2 C
Nicole S. Cunningham	-- -- --
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP	L3 A
Amanda R. Johnson	L2 B
David C. Vondle	L1 C
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3 A
John M. Jackson	L5 A
Robert P. Latham	L4 A
Covington & Burling LLP	L3 A
Jo Dale Carothers	L2 A
Laura U. Muschamp	-- -- --
Leslie N. Harvey	-- -- --
David A. Garr	-- -- --
Nixon Peabody LLP	L3 A
Christopher L. Ogden	L3 A
Ronald F. Lopez	L3 A
Robert E. Krebs	L3 A
Jennifer Hayes	L2 B
Sushila Chanana	L1 C
Benjamin T. Hickman	-- -- --
McGuirewoods LLP	L3 B
Brian C. Riopelle	L5 D
David E. Finkelson	L4 A
Robert M. Tyler	L3 B
Caitlin Lhommedieu	L2 A
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP	L3 B
David W. Hansen	L2 C
Ashish Nagdev	L2 D
Warren T. Allen, II	-- -- --
GibbonsLocal	L3 D
Thomas R. Desimone	L2 B
Frank A. Bruno	-- -- --
Shaw Keller LLPLocal	L3 E
Kevin P. B. Johnson	-- -- --
Eric M. Acker	-- -- --
Klarquist Sparkman LLP	L2 A
Jeffrey S. Love	L4 A
Spotts FainLocal	L2 A
Dana D. McDaniel	L4 A
Edward E. Bagnell, Jr.	L2 A
Spoots FainLocal	L2 A
Robert J. Barrett	-- -- --
Craig C ReillyLocal	L2 B
Craig C. Reilly	L4 A
Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky & Popeo	L2 D
Howard N. Wisnia	L3 A
Amster Rothstein & Ebenstein	L2 D
David A. Boag	L3 A
Abraham Kasdan	L3 C
Joseph M. Casino	L3 C
Daniel S. Ebenstein	L3 D
Heller Ehrman LLP	L2 D
Robert T. Haslam	L4 A
Michael M. Markman	L3 B
Leclair RyanLocal	L2 E
Megan S. Ben'Ary	-- -- --
Procopio Cory Hargreaves Savitch LLP	L1 E
Francis L. Tobin	-- -- --
Theodora Oringher Miller & RichmanLocal	-- -- --
David S. Richman	-- -- --
Patricia S. Riordan	-- -- --
Nick J. G. Sanchez	-- -- --
Walsh Colucci Lubeley Emrich & WalshLocal	-- -- --
Eugene A. Burcher	L2 C
Mulvaney Kahan & Barry LLPLocal	-- -- --
Patrick L. Prindle	-- -- --

No Attorneys