DCT

1:08-cv-00139

Flashpoint Technology Inc v. Aiptek Inc

General

Filed

03/07/08

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorCommunications

Status

Closed (09/01/15)

Patent Owner

NPE (W)

PACER

1:08-cv-00139

CourtD. Delaware

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Gregory M. Sleet	03/19/08 - 12/04/15	46%

Magistrate

Leonard P. Stark, Mary Pat Thynge

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Flashpoint Technology Inc NPE	L1 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Pepper Hamilton LLP	L5 A
William D. Belanger	L3 B
Alexandra C. Fennell	L2 A
Edmond D. Johnson	L2 D
Goutam Patnaik	L1 C
Michael D. Stone	L1 D
Frank Liu	-- -- --
James G. McMillan, III	-- -- --
Tuhin Ganguly	-- -- --
Gwendolyn Tawresey	-- -- --
Gregory Len	-- -- --
Andrew H. Devoogd	-- -- --
Ballard Spahr LLP	L3 B
David J. Margules	-- -- --
Kelley Drye & Warren LLP	L2 E
David M. Hill	L4 E
Ward & Olivo	L1 E
Michael J. Zinna	L4 A
John F. Ward	L4 D
John W. Olivo, Jr.	L3 E
San Diego IP Law Group LLP	L1 E
Cody R. Lejeune	L1 D
Williford FirmLocal	-- -- --
Evan O. Williford	-- -- --
Ray Angelini IncLocal	-- -- --
James J. Merkins, Jr.	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
DXG Technology USA Inc	-- -- --
Aiptek Inc	-- -- --
Cellco Partnership Inc	L5 A
LG Electronics USA Inc	L5 A
LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA Inc	L5 A
Cingular Wireless LLC	L5 A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L5 A
Nokia Inc	L5 A
Wal-Mart Stores Inc	L4 A
Target Corp	L4 A
HTC Corp	L4 A
HTC America Inc	L4 A
T-Mobile USA Inc	L4 A
Sprint Spectrum LP	L4 A
Research In Motion Ltd	L4 A
Research In Motion Corp	L4 A
Motorola Wuhan Mobility Technologies Communication Co Ltd	L4 A
General Electric Co	L4 E
Walgreen Co	L3 A
Kyocera Wireless Corp	L3 A
Kyocera Communications Inc	L3 A
Palm Inc	L3 A
Pantech Wireless LLC NPE	L3 B
Pantech Wireless Inc NPE	L3 B
Pantech Corp NPE	L3 B
Pantech Co Ltd NPE	L3 B
Pantech & Curitel Communications Inc NPE	L3 B
Polaroid Corp	L2 B
Bushnell Inc	L1 B
Leica Camera Inc	L1 C
Leica Camera AG	L1 C
General Imaging Co	L1 C
Argus Camera Co LLC	L1 C
Sakar Intl Inc	L1 D
Vupoint Solutions Inc	-- -- --
Vistaquest Corp	-- -- --
Tabata USA Inc	-- -- --
Sea & Sea	-- -- --
Ritz Interactive Inc	-- -- --
Ritz Camera Centers Inc	-- -- --
Mustek Inc	-- -- --
Minox USA Inc	-- -- --
Minox GmbH	-- -- --
Intl Norcent Tech	-- -- --
Oregon Scientific Inc	-- -- --
DXG Technology Corp	-- -- --
Digital Concepts	-- -- --
LG Electronics Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Kirkland & Ellis LLP	L5 A
Russell E. Levine	L4 E
Nyika O. Strickland	L3 D
Paul D. Collier	L3 D
Joel R. Merkin	L1 E
Perkins Coie LLP	L5 A
Ramsey M. Al-Salam	L5 A
Kaustuv M. Das	L5 B
John P. Schnurer	L4 B
Matthew C. Bernstein	L4 C
Philip A. Morin	L2 A
Kevin Patariu	L2 A
Cheng C. Ko	L2 C
Di Zhang	L1 C
Brian Wacter	-- -- --
Bancroft PLLC	L5 A
Christopher J. Coulson	-- -- --
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
David C. Doyle	L5 A
Mark A. Woodmansee	L4 A
Gregory W. Reilly	L3 A
Connolly Bove Lodge & Hutz	L5 A
Arthur G. Connolly, III	L4 A
Collins J. Seitz, Jr.	L1 B
Kevin F. Brady	-- -- --
Novak Druce Quigg LLP	L5 A
Paul E. Crawford	L2 D
Potter Anderson & Corroon LLPLocal	L5 A
Richard L. Horwitz	L5 A
David E. Moore	L5 A
Philip A. Rovner	L5 C
Doungamon Fon Muttamara-Walker	L3 A
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5 A
Michelle A. Flores	L3 A
Marc N. Henschke	L2 D
Baker Botts LLP	L5 B
David G. Wille	L4 B
Peter J. Chassman	L3 A
Samir Bhavsar	L3 A
Steven G. Schortgen	L3 A
Robert J. Benson	L3 B
Jay B. Johnson	-- -- --
Richards Layton & Finger PALocal	L5 B
Frederick L. Cottrell, III	L5 A
Steven J. Fineman	L5 B
Jeffrey L. Moyer	L5 E
Anne S. Gaza	L5 E
Travis S. Hunter	L4 D
Sarah R. Stafford	L3 A
Elizabeth Rui He	L3 C
Knobbe Martens Olson & Bear LLP	L5 B
Irfan A. Lateef	L5 A
Joseph R. Re	L5 E
Marko Zoretic	L2 C
Sidley Austin LLP	L5 B
Li Chen	L5 C
James P. Bradley	L4 A
Theodore W. Chandler	L4 B
Christopher P. Broderick	L3 A
Tung Nguyen	L2 A
Peter H. Kang	L2 B
Daniel J. Galligan	-- -- --
Crowell & Moring LLP	L4 A
Mark M. Supko	L3 A
Jeffrey D. Sanok	L3 B
Brian M. Koide	L3 C
Ann M. Mace	-- -- --
Covington & Burling LLP	L4 A
Michael K. Plimack	L4 D
Michael M. Markman	L3 A
David A. Garr	L2 C
Faegre Baker Daniels LLP	L4 A
Kenneth A. Liebman	L4 E
James R. Steffen	-- -- --
Matthew Stump	-- -- --
Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP	L4 A
Francis Digiovanni	L5 A
Ashby & GeddesLocal	L4 B
John G. Day	L5 A
Tiffany G. Lydon	L5 B
Steven J. Balick	L5 E
Duane Morris LLP	L4 C
Daniel V. Folt	L3 A
Matt Neiderman	L3 A
Gary W. Lipkin	L2 B
King & Spalding LLP	L4 D
Robert F. Perry	L5 A
Allison H. Altersohn	L4 C
Alexas D. Skucas	L3 A
Daniel C. Miller	L1 C
Shaw Keller LLPLocal	L3 B
John W. Shaw	L5 A
Karen E. Keller	L5 E
Brian L. Ferrall	L1 C
Michael H. Jacobs	-- -- --
Ryan J. McBrayer	-- -- --
Robert A. van Nest	-- -- --
Eric M. Acker	-- -- --
Keker van Nest & Peters LLP	L3 B
Eugene M. Paige	L3 C
Vinson & Elkins LLP	L3 B
Christopher Kao	L4 A
David J. Tsai	L4 A
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3 B
Richard De Bodo	L5 A
David H. Ben-Meir	L3 A
J. Drew Diamond	L1 A
Huan-Yi Lin	-- -- --
Wiley Rein LLP	L3 C
Kevin P. Anderson	L5 A
James H. Wallace, Jr.	L5 C
Robert J. Scheffel	L4 C
Brian H. Pandya	L4 E
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L3 C
William P. Atkins	L4 C
Samuel E. Stubbs	L2 B
Michael Bednarek	L2 C
Christopher K. Dorsey	L1 D
Morris James LLPLocal	L3 C
Mary B. Matterer	L5 A
Richard K. Herrmann	L5 C
Richard D. Kirk	L5 E
Ratner Prestia	L3 C
Rex A. Donnelly, IV	L1 C
Squire Patton Boggs US LLP	L3 D
Matthew E. Digby	-- -- --
Bayard PALocal	L3 E
Stephen B. Brauerman	L5 E
Phillips Goldman McLaughlin & Hall PALocal	L3 E
Megan C. Haney	L5 B
Sayles Werbner	L3 E
Jiri F. Smetana	-- -- --
Sheldon Mak AndersonLocal	L2 B
Douglas H. Morseburg	L3 A
Marc Karish	-- -- --
Saul Ewing LLP	L2 B
Whitney W. Deeney	L1 C
Candice T. Aaron	-- -- --
Sherry H. Flax	-- -- --
Theodore Naccarella	-- -- --
Smith Katzenstein & Jenkins LLPLocal	L2 D
Neal C. Belgam	L4 E
Kelly A. Green	-- -- --
Rossman Law PLLC	L2 E
Travis A. Rossman	-- -- --
Ezra Sutton P A	L1 C
Ezra Sutton	L3 B
HC Park & Associates	L1 C
Wayne M. Helge	L3 A
Hae-Chan Park	L2 A
Hovey Williams LLP	L1 D
Scott R. Brown	L4 C
Jennifer C. Bailey	L2 E
Wang Hartmann Gibbs & Cauley	L1 E
John D. van Loben Sels	L4 E
Richard F. Cauley	L4 E
Franklin E. Gibbs	L4 E
Jennifer L. Ishimoto	L3 E
Ellen J. Wang	L2 A
Frisenda Quinton Nicholson	L1 E
Frank Frisenda	L3 E
Ostrolenk Faber LLP	L1 E
Douglas A. Miro	-- -- --
Lawrence S. Rosenthal	-- -- --
Chen Malin LLP	L1 E
Jenny Chen	-- -- --
Klehr Harrison Harvey Branzburg & Ellers LLP	L1 E
David S. Eagle	L2 E
Parkowski Guerke & Swayze PALocal	-- -- --
Thomas H. Kovach	-- -- --
John C. Andrade	-- -- --
Michael W. McDermott	-- -- --
Michael W. Arrington	-- -- --
East West Law GroupLocal	-- -- --
Richard Kim	-- -- --

No Attorneys