DCT

1:12-cv-06291

Unified Messaging Solutions LLC v. Facebook Inc

General

Filed

09/07/12

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorSoftware, Security

Status

Closed (06/16/14)

Patent Owner

NPE (L)

PACER

1:12-cv-06291

Appeals

14-1611

CourtN.D. Illinois

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Joan H. Lefkow	09/18/12 - 12/12/17	68%
Leonard E. Davis	03/16/11 - 09/18/12	35%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
Unified Messaging Solutions LLC NPE	L5 E

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5 E
Jack W. Hill	L5 A
Thomas J. Ward, Jr.	L5 E
Albritton Law FirmLocal	L4 D
Stephen E. Edwards	L3 E
Nelson Bumgardner Conroy	L2 D
Eric M. Albritton	L4 B
Nelson Bumgardner Albritton	L2 D
Edward R. Nelson, III	L4 B
Brent N. Bumgardner	L3 A
Christie B. Lindsey	L3 C
Jonathan H. Rastegar	L2 D
Thomas C. Cecil	L1 C

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Facebook Inc	L3 A
Verizon Data Services LLC	L5 A
Verizon Communications Inc	L5 A
LinkedIn Corp	L5 A
T-Mobile USA Inc	L4 A
Research In Motion Ltd	L4 A
Research In Motion Corp	L4 A
Comcast Corp	L3 A
Comcast Cable Communications LLC	L3 A
Matchcom LLC	L3 A
Matchcom Inc	L3 A
Bank of America National Association	L3 D
Bank of America NA	L3 D
Bank of America Corp	L3 D
Charter Communications LLC	L2 C
Charter Communications Inc	L2 C
TXU Energy Retail Co LLC	L2 E
Windstream Corp	L1 B
Regions Financial Corp	L1 B
Regions Bank	L1 B
Comerica Inc	L1 B
Comerica Bank	L1 B
Cequel Communications LLC	L1 B
SUDDENLINK Communications	L1 C
E Trade Financial Corp	L1 C
E Trade Bank	L1 C
Eharmony Inc	L1 C
ETrade Financial Corp	L1 C
Reliant Energy Retail Holdings LLC	L1 E
Reliant Energy Inc	L1 E
True Beginnings LLC	-- -- --
Atmos Energy Services LLC	-- -- --
Atmos Energy Corp	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP	L5 A
Rick L. Rambo	L3 B
Thomas R. Davis	L2 A
Jackob Ben-Ezra	-- -- --
Winston & Strawn LLP	L5 A
Charles B. Molster, III	L3 E
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Allen F. Gardner	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
Patrick C. Clutter	L3 E
Ireland Carroll & KelleyLocal	L5 A
Otis W. Carroll, Jr.	L5 A
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 B
Richard De Bodo	L5 A
John M. Guaragna	L5 E
Jeffrey L. Johnson	L3 A
Andrew V. Devkar	L3 B
Claudia W. Frost	L3 C
Patrick S. Park	L2 A
Fish & Richardson	L5 C
Neil J. McNabnay	L5 A
Thomas B. Walsh, IV	L3 B
Jane J. Du	L3 D
Michael A. Bittner	L3 E
Taj J. Clayton	L2 B
Wasif H. Qureshi	L2 D
Katrina G. Eash	L2 D
Siebman Burg Phillips & Smith LLPLocal	L4 A
Clyde M. Siebman	L4 E
Orrick Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP	L4 A
Matthew J. Hult	-- -- --
Cooley LLP	L4 B
Heidi Keefe	L5 A
Mark Weinstein	L5 A
Michael G. Rhodes	L4 A
Lam K. Nguyen	L1 C
Sudhir A. Pala	-- -- --
Duane Morris LLP	L4 C
L. Norwood Jameson	L4 B
Matthew S. Yungwirth	L3 A
David M. Maxwell	L2 A
Allison H. Hutton	-- -- --
Irell & Manella LLP	L4 D
Morgan Chu	L5 A
Andrei Iancu	L4 A
Alan J. Heinrich	L4 B
Eric B. Hanson	L3 A
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L4 E
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L3 A
Michael E. Richardson	L3 A
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	L2 A
Jenner & Block LLP	L3 B
Bradford P. Lyerla	L4 A
Reginald J. Hill	L4 D
Peter H. Hanna	-- -- --
Brooks Kushman	L3 D
Matthew M. Jakubowski	L2 C
Christopher C. Smith	L2 C
Steptoe & Johnson LLP	L3 E
Paul A. Gennari	L3 B
John M. Caracappa	L3 B
Keker van Nest & Peters LLP	L2 B
Matthias A. Kamber	L2 A
David J. Silbert	L2 B
John C. Bostic	-- -- --
Dacus FirmLocal	L2 B
Deron R. Dacus	L4 B
Carstens & Cahoon LLP	L1 E
Zachary W. Hilton	L3 E
Vincent J. Allen	L2 D
Lance Lee	-- -- --
Lance Lee	-- -- --

No Attorneys