DCT

2:06-cv-00072

DataTreasury Corp v. Wells Fargo & Co

General

Filed

02/24/06

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

Status

Closed (08/03/11)

Patent Owner

NPE (W)

PACER

2:06-cv-00072

Appeals

07-1317

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
David Folsom	04/12/06 - 10/17/17	43%

Magistrate

Earl S. Hines, Amos L. Mazzant, III, John D. Love...
Charles C. Everingham, IV, Caroline M. Craven

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
DataTreasury Corp NPE	L2 E
Tgip Inc	-- -- --
Data Treasury Corp NPE	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Ward & Smith Law FirmLocal	L5 E
Thomas J. Ward, Jr.	L5 B
Albritton Law FirmLocal	L4 C
Eric M. Albritton	L5 A
Adam A. Biggs	L5 A
Kendall Law Group LLPLocal	L1 B
Elton Joe Kendall	L3 A
Karl A. Rupp	-- -- --
Dreier LLP	L1 D
Arianna Frankl	-- -- --
Marc S. Dreier	-- -- --
Caldwell Cassady Curry	-- -- --
Bradley W. Caldwell	L4 B
Nix Patterson & Roach LLPLocal	-- -- --
Andrew J. Wright	-- -- --
Edward L. Hohn	-- -- --
Edward K. Chin	-- -- --
Nelson J. Roach	-- -- --
Anthony K. Bruster	-- -- --
Rodney A. Cooper	-- -- --
Nida Nadir	-- -- --
Harold W. Nix	-- -- --
Nicole R. Kliewer	-- -- --
Nix Patterson Roach LLPLocal	-- -- --
Louis B. Paddock	-- -- --
David N. Smith	-- -- --
Derek Tod Gilliland	-- -- --
Richard B. King	-- -- --
Charles C. Patterson	-- -- --
Ostrow Kaufman & Frankl LLP	-- -- --
Seth H. Ostrow	L3 E
Matthew L. Kaufman	-- -- --
Elyssa S. Lane	-- -- --
Jeanpierre J. Giuliano	-- -- --
Gilbert's LLPLocal	-- -- --
Sara C. Zborovski	-- -- --
Shonagh McVean	-- -- --
Alexander J. Stack	-- -- --
Elizabeth S. Depchand	-- -- --
Timothy H. Gilbert	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Wells Fargo & Co	L1 A
Verizon Communications Inc	L5 A
MCI Communications Services Inc	L5 A
Bell Atlantic Communications Inc	L5 A
AT&T Mobility LLC	L4 A
Compass Bank	L3 A
Compass Bancshares Inc	L3 A
Citizens Financial Group Inc	L3 A
PNC Financial Services Group Inc	L3 A
PNC Bank National Association	L3 A
National City Corp	L3 A
National City Bank	L3 A
Zions First National Bank	L3 C
Zions Bancorp	L3 C
US Bank National Association	L3 C
US Bancorp Corp	L3 C
Telecheck Services Inc	L2 A
First Data Corp	L2 A
Comerica Inc	L2 B
Comerica Bank & Trust NA	L2 B
Comerica Bank	L2 B
Suntrust Banks Inc	L2 C
Suntrust Bank	L2 C
Branch Banking Trust Co	L2 C
BB&T Corp	L2 C
Bank of New York Mellon Corp	L2 C
Bank of New York Co Inc	L2 C
Bank of New York	L2 C
Wells Fargo Bank National Association	L1 A
Wachovia Corp	L1 A
Wachovia Bank NA	L1 A
Remitco LLC	L1 A
Toronto-Dominion Bank	L1 B
Toronto Dominion Bank	L1 B
RBS Citizens NA	L1 B
Keycorp	L1 B
Keybank National Association	L1 B
Bancorpsouth Inc	L1 B
Bancorpsouth Bank	L1 B
Electronic Data Systems Corp	L1 C
Lasalle Bank National Association	L1 C
Lasalle Bank NA	L1 C
Lasalle Bank Corp	L1 C
Bank of America National Association	L1 C
Bank of America Corp	L1 C
HSBC North America Holdings Inc	L1 C
HSBC Bank USA NA	L1 C
First Tennessee Bank National Association	L1 C
First Tennessee Bank NA	L1 C
First Horizon National Corp	L1 C
Frost National Bank	L1 C
Cullen Frost Bankers Inc	L1 C
Harris NA	L1 D
Harris Bankcorp Inc	L1 D
Bank of Montreal	L1 D
M&T Bank Corp	L1 D
M & T Bank Corp	L1 D
M & T Bank	L1 D
All Defendants	L1 D
Viewpointe Archive Services LLC	-- -- --
UBS Americas Inc	-- -- --
Symcor Inc	-- -- --
Royal Bank of Canada	-- -- --
National Bank of Canada	-- -- --
MT Bank	-- -- --
Unionbancal Corp	-- -- --
Union Bank of California National Association	-- -- --
Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi Ufj Ltd	-- -- --
Magtek Inc	-- -- --
Layn R Phillips	-- -- --
Hon Layn R Phillips	-- -- --
First-Citizens Bank Trust Co	-- -- --
First-Citizens Bank & Trust Co	-- -- --
First Citizens Bancshares Inc	-- -- --
Deutsche Bank Trust Co	-- -- --
Small Value Payments Co LLC	-- -- --
Clearing House Payments Co LLC	-- -- --
City National Bank	-- -- --
Intria Items Inc	-- -- --
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce	-- -- --
BBT Corp	-- -- --
Bank of Novia Scotia	-- -- --
Bank of Nova Scotia	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5 A
Kimberly K. Dodd	L3 D
Anthony H. Son	L3 E
Clarence E. Polk, Jr.	-- -- --
John J. Feldhaus	-- -- --
John T. Gutkoski	-- -- --
George C. Beck	-- -- --
Lisa S. Mankofsky	-- -- --
Jason J. Keener	-- -- --
Liane M. Peterson	-- -- --
Ryan S. Bewersdorf	-- -- --
Michael C. Lueder	-- -- --
Sidley Austin LLP	L5 A
James P. Bradley	L4 A
Catherine I. Rajwani	L4 B
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L4 E
Edward G. Poplawski	L4 E
Jennifer L. Jadlow	L3 E
Jeffrey A. Finn	-- -- --
Carissa A. Tener	-- -- --
Tung Nguyen	-- -- --
Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP	L5 A
Stephen E. Baskin	L3 A
Amr O. Aly	L3 B
William H. Boice	L3 B
Steven Gardner	L3 B
Jon R. Pierce	L3 C
Leroy M. Toliver	L2 C
Alton Absher, III	-- -- --
Eric L. Sophir	-- -- --
Audra A. Dial	-- -- --
E. Danielle Thompson Williams	-- -- --
Michael J. Turton	-- -- --
Bret T. Winterle	-- -- --
Wilson L. White	-- -- --
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L5 A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5 A
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale Dorr LLP	L5 A
Wayne L. Stoner	L5 E
Irah H. Donner	-- -- --
John M. Hintz	-- -- --
Christie Parker & Hale LLP	L5 A
David A. Dillard	L3 C
Joel A. Kauth	-- -- --
Potter MintonLocal	L5 B
E. Glenn Thames, Jr.	L5 C
Michael E. Jones	L5 E
Andrews Kurth Kenyon LLP	L5 B
John H. McDowell, Jr.	L3 A
Tonya M. Gray	L3 E
Gerald C. Conley	L1 D
Alston & Bird LLP	L5 B
Ross R. Barton	L2 A
McKool Smith	L5 B
Samuel F. Baxter	L5 A
Theodore Stevenson, III	L5 B
Garret W. Chambers	L4 A
Martin C. Robson	L4 A
Robert M. Manley	L4 D
Scott W. Hejny	L3 A
Luke F. McLeroy	L3 B
William E. Davis, III	L3 C
Laurie L. Fitzgerald	L2 A
Jill F. Lynch	L2 B
Douglas C. Edwards	L2 D
Peter J. Ayers	L1 D
David Sochia	-- -- --
Kevin Kneupper	-- -- --
Ivan Wang	-- -- --
Geoffrey L. Smith	-- -- --
Victoria Wicken	-- -- --
Lesley D. Anderson	-- -- --
Jennifer L. Henry	-- -- --
Capshaw Derieux LLPLocal	L5 D
Elizabeth L. Derieux	L5 C
Sidney C. Capshaw, III	L5 E
Fish & Richardson	L5 D
Juanita R. Brooks	L5 A
Michael B. Johnson	L4 B
Thomas M. Melsheimer	L3 A
Michael M. Rosen	L3 A
Lewis E. Hudnell, III	L3 D
Michael A. Bittner	-- -- --
Timothy Devlin	-- -- --
P. Weston Musselman, Jr.	-- -- --
Robert C. Earle	-- -- --
John M. Helms	-- -- --
Taj J. Clayton	-- -- --
DLA Piper US LLP	L5 D
Jeffrey L. Johnson	L2 D
Amy P. Mohan	-- -- --
Parker Bunt & AinsworthLocal	L5 E
Robert M. Parker	L5 A
Andrew T. Gorham	L5 B
Robert C. Bunt	L5 E
Charles Ainsworth	L5 E
Spangler Law LongviewLocal	L4 A
Andrew W. Spangler	L5 A
Fitzpatrick Cella Harper & Scinto	L4 B
Ronald A. Clayton	-- -- --
Stephen E. Belisle	-- -- --
Baker Botts LLP	L4 E
Kevin E. Cadwell	L4 A
Timothy S. Durst	L4 E
Larry D. Carlson	L3 D
Jeffrey A. Lamken	L3 D
Steven G. Schortgen	-- -- --
Fernando Rodriguez, Jr.	-- -- --
Chad Pinson	-- -- --
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L5 E
Jennifer P. Ainsworth	L5 E
Gillam & Smith LLPLocal	L4 E
Harry Lee Gillam, Jr.	L5 E
Roth Law FirmLocal	L3 A
Amanda A. Abraham	L5 A
Carl R. Roth	L5 B
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L3 A
Glen M. Boudreaux	-- -- --
Tim S. Leonard	-- -- --
Edward J. Nicholas	-- -- --
Carl R RothLocal	L3 A
Michael C. Smith	L5 A
Brendan C. Roth	L2 A
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L3 A
William P. Atkins	L4 A
Robert M. Fuhrer	-- -- --
Guillermo E. Baeza	-- -- --
Raymond L. Sweigart	-- -- --
Scott J. Pivnick	-- -- --
Vinson & Elkins LLP	L3 B
Scott W. Breedlove	L2 B
William L. Lafuze	-- -- --
Andrew E. Jackson	-- -- --
D. Ferguson McNiel	-- -- --
Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom LLP	L3 B
P. Anthony Sammi	-- -- --
Paramjeet S. Sammi	-- -- --
James Y. Pak	-- -- --
Joseph R. Sozzani	-- -- --
Marti A. Johnson	-- -- --
Mayer Brown LLP	L3 C
Jeremy P. Welch	-- -- --
Irell & Manella LLP	L3 C
Layn R. Phillips	L2 C
Elizabeth L. Rosenblatt	-- -- --
Baker & McKenzie LLP	L3 D
John G. Flaim	L2 C
W. Barton Rankin	-- -- --
Kevin M. O'Brien	-- -- --
Jay F. Utley	-- -- --
Charles Dick	-- -- --
Brian J. Hurst	-- -- --
Howard N. Wisnia	-- -- --
James P. Conley	-- -- --
Beck Redden & SecrestLocal	L3 D
Michael E. Richardson	L5 D
David J. Beck	L5 E
Joe W. Redden, Jr.	L1 A
Robert D. Daniel	-- -- --
Timothy A. Cleveland	-- -- --
Germer Gertz LLPLocal	L3 D
Lawrence L. Germer	L5 E
Charles W. Goehringer, Jr.	L5 E
Karen R. Bennett	-- -- --
Paul Hastings LLP	L3 E
Robert M. Masters	L4 E
Christopher W. Kennerly	L3 B
Paul J. Wilson	-- -- --
Brandon White	-- -- --
Haynes & Boone LLP	L2 A
Phillip B. Philbin	L4 A
John R. Emerson	L3 A
Claude E WelchLocal	L2 C
Claude E. Welch	L4 C
Sullivan & Cromwell LLP	L1 D
James T. Williams	-- -- --
Jane J. Jaang	-- -- --
Bruce E. Clark	-- -- --
James H. Carter	-- -- --
Standley Law Group LLP	L1 E
Jeffrey S. Standley	L4 E
F. Michael Speed, Jr.	L4 E
James L. Kwak	L2 E
Charhon Callahan Robson Garza PLLC	-- -- --
Christopher T. Bovenkamp	-- -- --
Steven C. Callahan	-- -- --
Daffer McDaniel LLPLocal	-- -- --
Stacy L. Zoern	-- -- --
Kurt M. Sauer	-- -- --
Belair & Perrone LLPLocal	-- -- --
Gregory Perrone	-- -- --
Law Offices Of Richard GraingerLocal	-- -- --
George R. Grainger	-- -- --
Jeremy Michael Thompson EsqLocal	-- -- --
Jeremy M. Thompson	-- -- --
Flowers Davis LLPLocal	-- -- --
Preston W. McGee	-- -- --
Smith Weber LLPLocal	-- -- --
Robert W. Weber	-- -- --
Lance Lee	-- -- --
Lance Lee	-- -- --

No Attorneys