DCT

6:10-cv-00370

PACid Group LLC v. Best Buy Co Inc

General

Filed

07/27/10

Cause of ActionPatent Infringement

SectorComp. Arch. and Software

StatusClosed

Patent Owner

Operating Company

PACER

6:10-cv-00370

CourtE.D. Texas

Judge	Period	PO Win Rate
Leonard E. Davis	07/27/10 - 12/28/11	35%

Plaintiff

Party

Name	Ratings
PACid Group LLC NPE	L1 B

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Spangler Law LongviewLocal	L4 B
Andrew W. Spangler	L5 B
Russ August & Kabat	L2 D
Adam S. Hoffman	L5 B
Alexander C. D. Giza	L5 C
Marc A. Fenster	L5 E
Andrew D. Weiss	L4 A
Ni Law Firm PLLC	-- -- --
Hao Ni	-- -- --

No Attorneys

Defendant

Party

Name	Ratings
Best Buy Co Inc	L2 E
Foundry Networks Inc	L5 A
Brocade Communications Systems Inc	L5 A
Belair Networks	L5 C
Harman Intl Industries Inc	L5 E
Intermec Technologies Corp	L4 E
Intermec Intl Inc	L4 E
Intermec Inc	L4 E
Honeywell Intl Inc	L4 E
Hand Held Products Inc	L4 E
ARRIS Group Inc	L4 E
Utc Fire & Security Americas Corp	L3 A
United Technologies Corp	L3 A
Lexmark Intl Inc	L3 A
XM Satellite Radio Inc	L3 A
Sirius XM Radio Inc	L3 A
Satellite CD Radio Inc	L3 A
Ingenico Inc	L3 B
Ingenico Corp	L3 B
Microchip Technology Inc	L3 E
Ricoh USA Inc	L2 A
Ricoh Electronics Inc	L2 A
Ricoh Co Ltd	L2 A
Ricoh Americas Corp	L2 A
Psion Teklogix Inc	L2 A
Psion PLC	L2 A
MediaTek USA Inc	L2 A
MediaTek Inc	L2 A
Ef Johnson Technologies Inc	L2 B
Fortress Technologies Inc	L2 C
Yamaha Corp	L2 C
DSP Group Inc	L2 D
Melco Holdings Inc	L2 D
Buffalo Technology USA Inc	L2 D
Buffalo Inc	L2 D
Logitech Intl SA	L2 D
Logitech Inc	L2 D
Denon Electronics USA LLC	L2 D
VTech Telecommunications Ltd	L2 E
VTech Holdings Ltd	L2 E
VTech Communications Inc	L2 E
Kodak Americas Ltd	L2 E
Eastman Kodak Co	L2 E
Best Buy Stores LP	L2 E
Best Buy Purchasing LLC	L2 E
BBC Property Co	L2 E
Huawei Technologies Co Ltd	L1 A
Futurewei Technologies Inc	L1 A
Bluesocket Inc	L1 C
Actiontec Electronics Inc	L1 C
Novatel Wireless Solutions Inc	L1 C
Novatel Wireless Inc	L1 C
Inrange Technologies Corp	L1 C
TP-Link USA Corp	L1 D
SMC Networks Inc	L1 D
Archos Inc	L1 D
Toko America Inc	L1 E
Westell Technologies Inc	-- -- --
Westell Inc	-- -- --
Redpine Signals Inc	-- -- --
3e Technologies Intl Inc	-- -- --
ICOM America Inc	-- -- --
GCT Semiconductor Inc	-- -- --
Archos Sa	-- -- --
Allied Telesis Inc	-- -- --

No Parties

Attorney

Name	Ratings
Foley & Lardner LLP	L5 A
Jonathan R. Spivey	L4 A
William J. Robinson	L4 E
Clarence E. Polk, Jr.	L3 B
Nicola A. Pisano	-- -- --
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP	L5 A
Kevin P. B. Johnson	L5 A
Sean S. Pak	L5 A
Mark Tung	L3 A
Morrison & Foerster LLP	L5 A
Michael A. Jacobs	L5 A
Vincent J. Belusko	L5 A
Grant L. Kim	L2 A
Wendy J. Ray	L2 A
Martin M. Noonen	L2 A
Sidley Austin LLP	L5 A
V. Bryan Medlock, Jr.	L5 A
Marc R. Ascolese	L2 A
Potter MintonLocal	L5 A
Michael E. Jones	L5 A
Allen F. Gardner	L5 E
Heartfield Law FirmLocal	L5 A
J. Thad Heartfield	L5 A
M. Dru Montgomery	L4 B
Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP	L5 A
Rick L. Rambo	L3 E
Howrey LLP	L5 A
John D. Hamann	L4 E
Findlay CraftLocal	L5 A
Eric H. Findlay	L5 A
Roger B. Craft	L4 D
Goodwin Procter LLP	L5 B
Douglas Kline	L5 A
K&L Gates	L5 C
Michael J. Bettinger	L5 B
Roderick B. Williams	L4 E
John H. McDowell, Jr.	L3 A
Holly Hogan	L3 B
James G. Warriner	-- -- --
David S. Brun	-- -- --
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati	L5 E
James C. Yoon	L5 D
Jose C. Villarreal	L4 E
Brian D. Range	L4 E
Yar R. Chaikovsky	L3 D
Jackson Walker LLPLocal	L4 A
John M. Jackson	L3 A
Ramey & FlockLocal	L4 A
Walter T. Henson	L2 C
Reed Smith LLP	L4 B
Jonah D. Mitchell	L4 B
Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP	L4 B
Claudia W. Frost	L2 E
David A. Jakopin	-- -- --
Matthew W. Hindman	-- -- --
Robins Kaplan LLP	L4 E
Emmett J. McMahon	L4 A
Ryan M. Schultz	-- -- --
Wilson Robertson & CorneliusLocal	L4 E
Melvin R. Wilcox, III	L4 D
William Cornelius	L3 D
Quarles & Brady LLP	L3 A
Nicole M. Murray	L4 B
Haynes & Boone LLP	L3 A
Phillip B. Philbin	L5 A
Donald E. Tiller	-- -- --
Hogan Lovells US LLP	L3 A
Korula T. Cherian	L5 E
Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP	L3 E
Josh A. Krevitt	L5 C
Benjamin Hershkowitz	L4 E
King & Spalding LLP	L3 E
Truman H. Fenton	L1 D
Jeffrey D. Mills	-- -- --
R. William Beard, Jr.	-- -- --
Bruce W. Slayden, II	-- -- --
Lerner David Littenberg Krumholz & Mentlik LLP	L3 E
Gregory S. Gewirtz	L4 C
McAndrews Held & Malloy LTD	L3 E
James R. Nuttall	-- -- --
Richard E. Dick	-- -- --
Morris Manning & Martin LLP	L2 B
John P. Fry	L5 D
Heather C. Brady	L3 B
Haltom & DoanLocal	L2 B
Darby V. Doan	L1 C
Morgan Day Vaughan	-- -- --
Rickey L FaulknerLocal	L2 E
Rickey L. Faulkner	L3 D
Vasquez Benisek Lindgren LLP	L1 D
Craig E. Davis	L5 A
Richard C. Vasquez	L4 C
Eric W. Benisek	L4 C
Stephen C. Steinberg	L4 C
Jeffrey T. Lindgren	L4 D
Freeborn & Peters LLP	L1 D
David S. Becker	L2 C
Jacob D. Koering	L2 D
Carson P. Veach	-- -- --
Darrick J. Hooker	-- -- --
Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP	L1 D
Jonathan Caplan	L3 D
Aaron M. Frankel	L3 E
Mark Baghdassarian	L3 E
Storm LLP	L1 E
Paul V. Storm	L5 D
Sarah M. Paxson	L2 E
Ostrow Kaufman & Frankl LLP	L1 E
Seth H. Ostrow	L4 E
Matthew L. Kaufman	-- -- --
Attorney & Counsel At LawLocal	-- -- --
Andy Tindel	L3 B
Sobel & Feller LLP	-- -- --
Mitchell S. Feller	-- -- --
Jonathan M. Sobel	-- -- --
Parker Firm	-- -- --
J. Chad Parker	-- -- --

No Attorneys